World Bank IMF and Dev Agencies | |
World Bank IMF and Dev Agencies | |
3505 VIEWS | |
![]() |
Tuesday,
May 21, 2019 12:05PM / By Petya Koeva Brooks, Martin Mühleisen, and Chad Steinberg, IMFBlog / Header Image Credit: ISTOCK
Download
Here – 2018 Review of Program Design and Conditionality
The IMF’s Review of Program Design and Conditionality
provides a deep look into the design of 133 IMF-supported lending programs in
operation between September 2011 and December 2017. This review is the first
major stocktaking of IMF programs since the Global Financial Crisis, a period
of unexpectedly slow economic growth.
Programs as shock absorbers
Countries often come to the IMF when they already face major threats to economic or financial stability. Hence, IMF programs serve as “shock absorbers,” enabling countries to meet immediate financial needs and significantly cushion economic distress. IMF programs also catalyze additional financing from the markets, other official lenders, and donors. This helps protect the countries’ economies from even greater disruption.
The
review found three-quarters of IMF programs were successful or partially
successful in achieving their objectives, such as resolving balance of payment
problems and fostering economic growth. Social spending was generally protected
as a share of GDP. Over a third of IMF programs, mostly in low-income
countries, targeted fiscal expansion to support growth and poverty reduction.
Lessons learned and way forward
The review also identified several factors that potentially inhibited programs from fully reaching their objectives. Overoptimistic economic forecasts reduced a program’s chances of success; accordingly, the review recommends using a more conservative approach to economic forecasts and providing deeper analyses of the impact that policies under the program could have on economic growth. More extensive contingency planning should also be included when designing programs.
Public debt is a case in point. Debt sustainability improved in most cases where debt vulnerabilities started out high. In some programs, however, debt exceeded the Fund’s initial projection by considerable margins. Fund policies are already in place to deal with unsustainable debt in Fund-supported programs. While any debt restructuring needs to be considered on a case-by-case basis, more careful diagnosis is essential—this means sharper tools for the IMF’s debt sustainability analysis are needed to reduce any bias in judgement when assessing debt.
The
review finds many programs applied fiscal adjustments that were less
growth-friendly than initially envisaged. Fiscal adjustment tended to be
achieved by cutting public investment, possibly curtailing future growth,
rather than by lowering current spending or raising revenue. To be a more
useful guide for the government’s fiscal policy, an IMF program could set more
granular targets, like a floor for critical public investments.
Tackling structural challenges to bolster growth prospects
Fund-supported programs could also do more to tackle deep-rooted structural challenges to improve a country’s long-term growth prospects. Comparing structural conditionality attached to programs with the recommendations found in preceding IMF surveillance reports, we found that programs generally kept closer to reforms that fell within the Fund’s traditional areas of expertise. We also found that conditionality in fragile and small states should be better tailored to these countries’ specific challenges.
Where
critical for achieving program goals, conditionality may also need to go beyond
traditional domains, such as fiscal and monetary policy, suggesting that the
Fund will need to build more expertise, for example, in labor and product
market reforms. We will also continue to collaborate with partner institutions
in areas where we do not have expertise. As reforms in some of these areas
could take longer to implement and yield results, the Fund could consider
extending the program duration of arrangements under the Extended Fund Facility
in exceptional cases to five years, alongside appropriate safeguards.
The importance of ownership
IMF-supported programs tended to be most successful when country authorities had strong ownership of the specified course of action. To foster this commitment, the IMF needs to put itself into the shoes of country authorities more often. A better understanding of domestic institutional and political capacities can avoid aiming at unrealistic targets. Also, tying programs in with national reform plans will make it easier for country authorities—and their citizens—to stay the course.
Effective communication with the public is often an underappreciated aspect of successful program implementation. The review recommends greater public information and engagement. If a program goes off-track, the Fund should strive to remain involved—for instance, by encouraging countries to use Staff-Monitored Programs that will help maintain the country’s track record in collaborating with the Fund.
In line with its commitment to be a learning institution, the Fund will draw on the lessons of the review to improve program design in the future. Moreover, the Fund will continue to conduct regular reviews of its conditionality.
Download
Here – 2018 Review of Program Design and Conditionality
Related News
1. After Finalizing
IMF Loan, Egypt’s Reforms Target Industrialization, Exports
2. Don’t Cry For Me
Argentina – An Open Letter To The IMF Regarding Ongoing Crisis In Argentina
3. Transcript of
IMF MD Christine Lagarde's Opening Press Conference, 2019 Spring Meetings
4. Navigating
Sub-Saharan Africa’s Recovery Amid Greater Uncertainty
5. Afreximbank’s
2018 Financial Statements Shows Growing Loan Book and Improving Interest
Margins
6. AfDB Approves
$4.8m For AfCFTA, Nigeria Assesses Impact
7. Weak Spots in
Global Financial System Could Amplify Shocks
8. The Global
Economy: A Delicate Moment
9. IMF Executive
Board Concludes 2019 Article IV Consultation with Nigeria
10. AfDB Helps to
Break Down The Barriers to Free Trade in Africa
11. AfDB Advances
Gender Equality in African Procurement
12. Afreximbank
Appoints Audit Director
13. African
Development Bank Holds Dialogue with Egyptian Government
14. Afreximbank
Names Maureen Mba Director for Compliance
15. AfDB, ECOWAS
Sign Agreement For Study On Abidjan-Lagos Corridor Highway
16. Statement On The
Memorandum By Embassies Of The USA, The UK, Netherlands, Germany And
Switzerland
17. Davos 2019:
World Bank Steps Up Commitment of $200bn to Global Climate Finance
18. 2019 World
Economic Outlook - A Weakening Global Expansion
19. African Economic
Outlook 2019: Growth Projected To Accelerate To 4pct in 2019 - AfDB
20. IFC, West
African Stock Exchange Partner to Strengthen Corporate Governance