Minister of Finance Approves TAT (Procedure) Rules, 2021

Proshare

Thursday, October 07, 2021 / 5:51 AM / by Wole Obayomi / Header Image Credit: Hogson Russ

 

The Honourable Minister of Finance, Budget and National Planning, Mrs. Zainab Shamsuna Ahmed, on 10 June 2021 approved the Tax Appeal Tribunal (TAT) (Procedure) Rules, 2021 ("the Rules"), pursuant to her powers under Section 61 of the Federal Inland Revenue Service (Establishment) Act, 2007 (as amended).

 

The Rules, which replaces the defunct TAT (Procedure) Rules, 2010, enables the Tribunal to deal justly, fairly and expeditiously with appeals and encourages and promote the settlement of disputes among parties.  


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd. 


We have highlighted below some key changes to the Rules as follows: 

  • Requirement for taxpayers to pay 50% of any disputed amount into a designated account of the TAT as security for prosecuting an appeal, prior to commencement of appeals.
  • Modification of some old definitions, and interpretation of additional terms such as "appeal", "notice of appeal", "decision of the Tribunal" etc.
  • Recognition of service of documents or processes carried out by email or such other electronic means as the Tribunal may permit.
  • Recognition of virtual/ remote hearing of applications and delivery of rulings by the Tribunal.
  • Introduction of a six-month timeframe from the date of commencement of trial for the TAT to conclude and provide a decision.
  • Provisions for hearing of ex-parte and non-contentious applications in Chambers as well as summary appeal procedure for liquidated money demands.

 

Although the TAT (Procedure) Rules, 2010 is effectively replaced, the Rules allows for "anything done" under the defunct 2010 Rules to remain valid, as long as such is not inconsistent with the provisions of the new Rules, thereby grandfathering existing matters and ensuring a smooth transition.

 

Comments

 

The implementation of the new Rules emphasizes the Federal Government's commitment to improving Nigeria's tax landscape, which commenced with the enactment of Finance Acts, 2019 and 2020.  The amendments to the TAT (Procedure) Rules, which is the initial forum for formal tax adjudication in Nigeria, align with changes in global tax administration systems and would ensure that the TAT's procedures are up to date and give taxpayers increased confidence in the system.

 

However, the introduction of a blanket requirement for taxpayers to make a 50% deposit of disputed amounts to the TAT may act as a clog in the wheels of justice and discourage taxpayers from pursuing recourse from the TAT.  This requirement also deviates from the provisions of the Section 15(7) of Federal Inland Revenue (Establishment) Act that permits such deposits only on certain circumstances.  Further, there is a risk that the blanket requirement may make the TAT more litigious in its outlook, and takes it away from the less formal dispute resolution framework it was designed to be.  It may also increase the risk of tax disputes being resolved based on rules of court or technicality, rather than substantive justice, a weakness of the formal court system which the TAT is set up to provide.

 

The role of the Tax Commissioners are not those of "judges" in the constitutional sense and so, rather than becoming a part of the judiciary, the TAT should be preparatory to, and supplementary to the formal judicial system.  Therefore, the changes may revive the challenges on the legality of the TAT and its encroachment on the constitutional preserve of the Federal High Court on revenue and taxation issues.  

 

The Honourable of Minister should, therefore, consider making the TAT Rules less litigious or court-like to ensure the TAT maintains its edge as a speedy and non-litigious tax dispute resolution forum.

 

Download Here - TAT Procedures Rules 2021

 

Credits

* This statement was first published in the Issue 10.1/ October 2021 Newsletter of KPMG of Wednesday, October 07, 2021. For further enquiries, please contact the author, Wole Obayomi via ng-fmtaxenquiries@ng.kpmg.com


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related to TAT

  1. TAT Rules on the Validity of Tax Assessments Following Taxpayer's Failure to Object
  2. Tax Appeal Tribunal Provides Criteria for WHT Exemption
  3. Tax Appeal Tribunal Delivers Conflicting Decisions on Whether VAT is Chargeable on Property Leases
  4. Tax Tribunal Rules That A Taxpayer Can Object To A Defective Assessment Even If It Has Been Paid
  5. TAX Appeal Tribunal Rules That Rent is Not Subject to VAT
  6. Tax Appeal Tribunal Delivers Judgement in Maiden Transfer Pricing Case in Nigeria
  7. Tax Appeal Tribunal Delivers Landmark Decision on Threshold for Exported Service
  8. Tax Appeal Tribunal Rules In Favour Of Taxpayers In Two Successive Landmark Judgment
  9. Tax Appeal Tribunal Delivers Landmark Ruling against Abia State Board
  10. Tax Appeal Tribunal Rules That Excess Dividend Is Liable To Tax At 30%
  11. Federal Government Reconstitutes the Tax Appeal Tribunal
  12. Using the Tax Appeal Tribunal as an Instrument of Promoting a National Tax Policy
  13. Tax Appeal Tribunal's Jurisdiction viz-a-viz the Federal High Court


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related News on Taxes and Tariffs

  1. Dangote Cement, MTN Pay Highest Income Tax to FG in 2020
  2. Administration of Stamp Duties in Nigeria - Concluding Part
  3. Administration of Stamp Duties in Nigeria Under The Finance Act - Part 3
  4. The New VAT Combat is a Protest - Teniola
  5. Does The Federal Government Have the Constitutional Powers to Legislate on VAT?
  6. A State-controlled VAT System will Slow MSME Growth in Nigeria - Yomi Olugbenro
  7. Insights on VAT Collection and Distribution in Nigeria - Ayo Teriba
  8. Highlights of the Lagos State Value-Added Tax Law
  9. Rivers State Government Seeks Redress at Supreme Court over COA Decision
  10. Examining The Contentious Issues Arising from The Federal High Court (FIRS) Practice Directions
  11. The VAT Debate Continues; Rivers State Govt Files An Appeal at the Supreme Court
  12. Federal High Court's Practice Direction for FIRS


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP