Insights on VAT Collection and Distribution in Nigeria - Ayo Teriba

Proshare

Monday, September 20, 2021 / 7:07 AM / By Ayo Teriba / Header Image Credit: Ecographics

 

As some States lock horns at the courts with the Federal Government to assert their democratic collection and distribution rights on Value Added Tax (VAT), we seem to have lost our way on a journey we started some three decades ago. This piece contributes to our efforts to retrace our steps.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



1.   Components of VAT

a. VAT on Intrastate/Intra-LG Transactions

Should the States win the battle to collect VAT within their jurisdictions on behalf of themselves and their constituent LGs, they can only collect VAT on intrastate transactions. Nothing should stop the LGs or major cities from following suit.

 

b. VAT on Interstate Transactions

VAT on interstate transactions, including Corporate VAT payments at headquarters, that transcend intrastate transactions are legitimately collectible and retainable by the FG and redistributable among all States based on equality of States/LGs and population.

 

c.  VAT on International Transactions

VAT on international transactions that transcend interstate and intrastate transactions are legitimately collectible and retainable by the FG and redistributable among all States based on equality of States/LGs and population.



The total VAT receipts at issue were about 1.5 trillion Naira or one percent of GDP in 2020. There seem to be a presumption in some circles that the bulk of the VAT are generated from intrastate transactions.


VAT receipts have never been broken down into federally generated international/interstate components on the one hand, and sub-nationally generated or 'internally generated' intrastate component on the other hand, or even intra-LG/intracity components that may well become an issue as our democratic quest for devolution take root. It is important to have such breakdown now.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

 

2.  Collection of VAT

a.  The Federal Government has been collecting all components of VAT on behalf of all tiers.

b. Two states now seek court rulings to collect VAT on behalf of themselves and LGs within their domains.

c.  Some LGs/Cities may well seek court rulings to collect VAT within their jurisdictions in the future.

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

3.  Distribution of VAT


The formulas for vertical and horizontal distribution of proceeds of value added tax (VAT) across the three tiers and within each of the two lower tiers of government are summed up as follows in the Keynote Address delivered by the then Honourable Minister of State for Finance, Mr Remi Babalola, at the National Workshop on the Review of the Revenue Sharing Formula of 6th May 2008:


"The Value Added Tax (VAT) was introduced in 1993 and it replaced Sales tax in the states. The formula for the distribution when it was first introduced was 50% to FGN; 35% to the States; and 15% to LGAs. With effect from January 1999, the formula was adjusted as follows: FGN 15%, States 50% and LGAs and area councils of the FCT 35%. The share of the States and that of the local Governments is shared amongst them using the factors of Equality 50%, population 30% and derivation 20%."

Source: Remi Babalola, (2008) Revenue Sharing Formula



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

4.  Some Ideal Ways Forward


Dispassionate resolution of the VAT distribution debacle calls for the following action points:

 

a. Publish Breakdowns of Proceeds from International, Interstate, and Intrastate VAT Components

It is important to know how much VAT accrues from intrastate, interstate, and international transactions.

 

b. Scrap the Vertical and Horizontal Distribution of Intrastate/Intra-LG/Intra-city VAT Components

The vertical and horizontal distribution formulas should not be applied to VAT receipts on intrastate transactions to allow each State/LG/City to retain the entire proceeds using only the principle of derivation, to effectively scrap the principles of 'equality' and 'population' which should have no place in distribution of value added tax on intrastate transactions that are 'internally generated revenue' of States/LGs/Cities.


c. Vertical Distribution Formula should apply to Interstate and International VAT Components

FG, States, and LGs should continue to share proceeds of VAT collected on Interstate and International Transactions based on the vertical allocation formula.

 

d. Horizontal Distribution Formula should apply to Interstate and International VAT Components

Once States/LGs are allowed to retain the full proceeds of VAT on intrastate transactions, horizontal distribution of the proceeds of VAT on interstate and international transactions should be based on equality and population as the only two guiding principles, derivation should no longer apply to these components.

 

e.  It should not matter who collects, once agreement is reached on who gets what from which components.

 

 

About the Author

The Author, Dr. Ayo Teriba is the CEO of Economic Associates  and can be reached via email at ayo.teriba@econassociates.com. Click here to go to Author's Page

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - Dr. Ayo Teriba /Economic Associates

1.  Economic Associate's Conference on Nigeria's Economic Outlook to Hold in 3 States this September - Proshare, 06 Sept, 2021

2.     VIDEO: Highlights of the June 2021 Economic Associates One-Day Nigerian Economic Outlook Conference

3.     Nigerian Economist Ayo Teriba Advises FG to Liberalize the Services Sector  June 24, 2021

4.     Dr. Ayo Teriba to Speak on Nigeria and The Trilemma Of Debt, Revenue and Liquidity  July 08, 2020

5.     Nigeria Needs to Generate Liquidity To Ensure Growth and Stability - Dr. Ayo Teriba , April 14, 2020

6.     Liquidity Still The Key Factor in Nigeria's Economic Stability in 2020 - Dr Ayo Teriba , December 17, 2019

7.     Awoyemi, Awosika, Teriba, Olukanni speak on Outlook for Nigeria's Economy In 2020 , December 17, 2019

8.     Unlocking Liquidity in Nigeria - Ayo Teriba , October 14, 2019

9.     Unlocking Liquidity Will Restore Growth and Stability for Nigeria - Ayo Teriba, July 19, 2019

10.  Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on April 10, 2019

11.   Africa Economic Outlook - Ayo TeribaMay 31, 2019

12.  Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on September 27, 2018

13.  Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on June 21, 2018



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - Taxes

1.      Highlights of the Lagos State Value-Added Tax Law

2.     Rivers State Government Seeks Redress at Supreme Court over COA Decision

3.     Examining The Contentious Issues Arising from The Federal High Court (FIRS) Practice Directions

4.     The VAT Debate Continues; Rivers State Govt Files An Appeal at the Supreme Court

5.     Federal High Court's Practice Direction for FIRS

6.     How to Fix Nigeria's Broken VAT System

7.     Court of Appeal Orders States to Maintain Status Quo on VAT Administration

8.     State Attorney Generals Sue AGF Over Stamp Duty Administration

9.     Administration of Stamp Duties in Nigeria Under The Finance Act - Part 2

10.  Lagos Assembly Passes VAT, Anti-Open Grazing Bills

11.   Lagos State Government Presents State VAT Bill

12.  FIRS Becomes Desperate Over a Clear Justifiable Matter, Writes NASS for Exclusive Powers

13.  FG vs States VAT War - Cutting Through the Noise

14.  Rivers State Government Orders Implementation of State VAT Law

15.  VAT: Court Dismisses FG's Motion for Stay of Judgment Execution

16.  Governor Wike Directs RSRS to Ensure Full Implementation of the VAT Judgement

17.  Administration of Stamp Duties in Nigeria Under The Finance Act

18.  e-book on Matters Arising from Implementation of Finance Act, 2020

19.  FG Reintroduces VAT on Cooking Gas

20. What You Should Know About The Rivers State Value-Added Tax Law



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP