October 28, 2021 / 06:30 PM / by Proshare Research / Header Image Credit:
In a move that reflected the resolution of a long-standing legacy issue concerning FBN Registrars, the FBNH Board has taken decisive action to appoint a new custodian of its shareholder records. In response to unfolding developments concerning old and new stakeholders in FBN Holdings (FBNH), the Holdco's Directors, in a Board meeting held on Thursday, October 27, 2021, approved the appointment of Meristem Registrars as a replacement for First Registrars and Investor Services Limited. The appointment will take effect from December 1, 2021. The corporate decisions of FBNH's Board set the tone for a broader response to industry-wide corporate governance integrity and credibility.
The Holdco's denial and reversal recently reflected the shimmering fluidity of the situation around its shareholding and the rapidly moving parts of a high-stakes corporate chess game. The outcome has since become known, but the consequence is indeterminable.
Chart October 1 Fever, FBNH Share Price Movement Dec. 2020 - October 22, 2021
Source: Proshare Research, NGX
The change of Registrar appears to be an intelligent and inevitable first response to concerns about the transparency of the Holdco's shareholding structure, painted in all shades of grey. The exact quantity of shares owned by significant stakeholders is still a mystery and this compromises the stock market's complete disclosure responsibility and integrity. The asymmetric nature of market information concerning the present shareholding structure of the financial Holdco is a challenge to the market's commitment to the highest professional standards of transparency. However, FBNH's Board's decision to use a new and, hopefully, independent Registrar is thus commendable. Nevertheless, this is one of several steps to navigate FBNH towards institutional best governance practices (see illustration 1 below).
Illustration 1 FBNH: Registrar Blues-From New to Old
The Matters Arising - In Whose Interest?
Beyond a change of Registrar, FBNH's Board will have to go further and clarify to the Nigerian Exchange Limited (NGX) and minority shareholders the following matters:
A Time for Rebirth
The challenges with FBNH's shareholding disclosures are not unique, nor do they represent the challenges of a troubled institution. These are natural pangs that arise when a system receives a jolt; in the case of FBNH, it has received a few, which has challenged the system and equally opened opportunities to learn, resolve legacy issues and refocus on banking fundamentals.
Beyond FBNH, these issues reflect the state of practice in the industry, and the regulators are now required to assume an industry approach to a review of rules, conventions, and requirements.
Analysts believe this may be the appropriate time for the capital market's regulatory bodies to clean the Augean stable of clandestine shareholdings by taking a detailed look at the ownership structures of other banks listed on the NGX. The need for the exercise becomes particularly important as many of the NGX's tier 1 banks have taken an impressive decision to grow their balance sheets continentally.
With more Nigerian banks going continental, the CBN, NGX, CAC, and SEC must protect the integrity of the financial system and lending institutions by ensuring that publicly available information is not only reliable, credible but provides a true and fair representation of corporate facts; especially in the disclosure requirements subject to professional liability claims.
Nigeria's capital market regulators cannot afford to drop the regulatory ball against the background of the African Continental Free Trade Agreement (AfCFTA), the African Exchanges Linkage Programme (AELP) and other growth-related and investment attraction schemes and policies of the government.
The fast-paced realities of continental equity and debt market growth over the next few months require a rebirth of equity market clarity, consistency and integrity. FBNH is simply a case study; the rules around market conduct are deeper and broader, with regulators required to ride the waves of new developments like a Badagry beach surfboard pro.
PDF - 100 Days After CBN's Board Removal: First Bank's Shaky House of Cards Report (PDF)
1. Executive Summary: 100 Days After CBN's Board Removal: First Bank's Shaky House of Cards - September 19, 2021
2. Full Report: 100 Days After CBN's Board Removal: First Bank's Shaky House of Cards - September 19, 2021
1. FBN Holdings Appoints Nnamdi Okonkwo as Group MD; UK Eke Retires; Renews Adeduntan's Appointment â€“ October 28, 2021
2. The Phoenix: Matters Arising as Otedola Acquires 5% Interest in FBNH â€“ October 25, 2021
3. FBN Holdings Notifies of a New Investor With Over 5% Stake - October 24, 2021
5. September 19, 2021
6. Of First Bank and Bad Debtors; A System's Throbbing Headache - April 30, 2021 - Proshare Editorial
7. CBN Removes Boards of First Bank of Nigeria, FBN Holdings; Appoints New Chairmen - April 29, 2021 - Proshare News
8. Analyzing the H1 2017 Performance of FBNHoldings Plc - A Comprehensive Report - October 23, 2017, Proshare Research
9. FBNHoldings Plc Q1' 2017 Performance Assessment Report Updated - September 25, 2017, Proshare Research
10. Bank NPLs (23) - The Case for a New Approach - June 07, 2020 - Debtors Africa
11. W. Chan Kim and Renee Mauborgne (2004) "Blue Ocean Strategy"
12. Board Governance: A Thin Line Between Oversight and Operations - September 28, 2020 - IoD Centre for Corporate Governance
13. Leadership, Change and Corporate Transformation - The Nigerian Experience November 07, 2017
14. CEO Remuneration 2021 Report: From COVID to Collaboration - August 01, 2021, Proshare Research
15. Memo to the Market - The NSE, Oscar Onyema Foundation and Corporate Governance - August 20, 2018, Olufemi Awoyemi, Proshare
16. FBN Holdings Plc - IR Page on Proshare MarketsProshare Research
17. Annual Accounts - IR Page in ProshareProshare Research
18. Bernard Longe wins suit against First Bank Plc, Supreme Court decides today - March 05, 2010, Proshare