Monday, August 01, 2016 9:18am/ FBNQuest Research
Event: Skye Bank reported Q4 2015 results
Implications: Limited; recent Skye-specific events have overtaken these results
Negatives: Loss before tax of –N53bn (our estimate was –N6.6bn)
Late last week Friday, after several months of delays, Skye Bank reported Q4 2015 results which showed that the bank made a pre-tax loss of –N53bn and an after tax loss of –N50bn.
The respective full year figures were –N38bn and –N37bn. There is very little conclusion to draw from these results beyond the obvious headline disappointment. Apart from the interest income and other comprehensive income lines, every other line was negative.
In effect, this was not down to just loan loss provisions, which admittedly were high at N21bn in just Q4: this was an extremely poor set of results that was broadbased. Both funding income and non-interest income were negative.
Relative to our forecasts, Skye disappointed across the board save for a positive surprise on the other comprehensive income line. We were expecting the bank to make a loss (-N6.6bn in pre-tax losses) but the scale of the loss was well beyond expectations.
As weak as these results may look, recent events have overshadowed them. The replacement of the board and management by newly appointed individuals by the central bank signaled there were major issues with Skye from both a liquidity and capital point of view.
Management disclosed that the CAR stood at 10% and that the CBN has injected about N100bn (1 year tenor) into the bank to prevent a run on it. Management indicated an NPL ratio of 13% for December.
We would expect that this ratio has worsened since then given that 50% of Skye’s loan book is in foreign currency – a reflection of the significant exposure the bank has to the oil and gas sector. We would expect the Q1 and Q2 2016 results to show further deterioration.
Skye has been among the worst performing names on the exchange this year. Year to date they are down –56% (ASI: -2.2%). There is a temptation to assume that the worst is out now with the start of the release of the bank’s earnings. We believe this is premature.
We have consistently held the view that tier 2 banks were likely to struggle as the macro environment worsened. Skye was at the top of our list of unfavourable names in this category. We remain cautious and will advise investors to continue to avoid the shares. We rate Skye Underperform. Our estimates are under review.
Skye Bank Q4 2015 results: actual vs. FBNQuest Research estimates (N millions)
Source: NSE; FBNQuest Estimates
1. SKYEBANK Declares N40.73bn Loss in 2015 Audited Results SP N0.70k
2. Tracking Skye bank’s Share Price: 15days After
3. Tracking Skye bank’s Share Price: 10days After
4. CBN Affirms Confidence in Skye Bank, Institutes Guarantee Line
5. Tracking Skye bank's Share Price: 5days After
6. Nigeria's Skye Bank Downgraded To 'CCC-' On Heightened Default Risk
7. Nigeria s Central Bank Takes Over Skye Bank - Sacks Board Over Capital Issues
8. Expectedly, S&P rates Skyebank a CCC+ on back of Economic & Liquidity Concerns
9. Skyebank and The Prolonged Delay on Earnings Announcement
10. Why investors should expect a contained earning from Skye Bank
11. The Surprising New Math of Acquisition of Banks in Nigeria – The Skye Bank Case
1. 10.Reworking the Acquisition Maths of Mainstreet Bank by Skye Bank Plc
12. CBN Reduces maximum limit of FX borrowing to 75% of Capital
13. Skye Bank Plc and AMCON Sign Agreement on Acquisition .- Proshare
14. Skye Bank - The Math Adds Up says CBN, Acquisition Payment of Mainstreet Bank Done – Nov 01, 2014
15. SKYEBANK Seeks Four-Week Extension to File its 2015 Audited Financial Statement
16. SKYEBANK Issues Earnings Guidance for Financial Year Ended 31st December 2015
17. All eyes still on Skye Bank s capital raise
18. How to buy a Nigerian bank with no money