Positive Surprise in Zenith Bank’s Q3 2017 Results, FBN Quest Lowers Cost of Risk


Wednesday, October 25, 2017   09:47 AM / FBNQuest Research 

7-8% increase to our 2017-18E EPS forecasts / price target:

We retain our Outperform recommendation on Zenith Bank (Zenith), following its Q3 2017 results which came in well ahead of expectations. We have lowered the cost-of-risk assumption driving our loan impairment forecast for 2017E by c.20bps to 3.0% to reflect the positive surprise in loan loss provisions in Q3 2017. 

This reduction underpins the 7% average increase to our earnings forecasts over the 2017-18E period and the 8% increase to our price target to N31.7. Our revenue forecasts have barely changed because weakness in funding income was offset by better-than-expected non-interest income. In contrast to Q2 2017 when fx trading income drove the solid growth in non-interest income, treasury bill trading income which was up markedly in Q3 was the primary driver behind the positive surprise in non-interest income. 

Consequently, we have raised our non-interest income forecast by around 31% on average over the 2017-18E period but cut our funding income forecasts by 14% on average. At current levels, Zenith Bank shares are trading on a 2017E P/B multiple of 1.0x for 21.3% ROAE in 2018E. This multiple represents a discount of 53% to the 2.1x P/B multiple (for 28.0% ROAE) that GT Bank is trading on. Our new price target implies a potential upside of 25% from current levels. 

PBT surprised positively; beat our forecast by 32%:
Zenith Bank’s Q3 2017 results showed low single digit y/y declines in both PBT and PAT. Although profit before provisions of N114bn showed a greater decline (-8% y/y), those on the provisions and opex lines proved significant, helping to limit the decline on the PBT line. Both revenue lines contributed to the decline in profit before provisions: while funding income was flattish, non-interest income fell -16% y/y because of base effects. 

Also on a q/q basis, because of base effects again, the bank recorded a marked fall of -42% q/q for non-interest income. Notwithstanding, non-interest income actually surprised positively, coming in much stronger than we had expected. Given a lackluster performance in funding income however, the impact of the better-than-expected non-interest income result was not felt. 

A significant positive surprise in loan loss provisions was the main reason for Zenith’s better-than-expected PBT (and PAT) result. 

Related News
1.       Zenith Bank Reports Q3 2017 Results Records Weaker Than Expected Funding Income
2.      Zenith Bank Plc Announces Closed Period
3.    Zenith Bank Plc. - Set for an Impressive FY-2017 Performance, Amid Credit Loss Pressure
4.      Zenith Bank Plc Announces the Retirement of Mr. Olusola Oladipo from Its Board.
5.    Zenith Bank Plc H1 2017 Conference Call & Earnings Presentation - The Key Takeaways
6.      Zenith Bank Plc H1 Results – Forward Hump Boosts Earnings  
7.      Zenith Bank Plc - Earnings Beat as FX Income Spike Dwarfs Huge Provision
8.     ZENITHBANK Declares N75.32bn PAT in Q2 2017 Results, Proposes 25 Kobo Interim Dividend (SP:N24.00k)
9.      ZENITHBANK Declares N37.49bn PAT in Q1 2017 Results, (SP:N14.9k)
10.  ZENITHBANK Declares N129.6bn PAT in 2016 Audited Results; Proposes N1.77k Final Dividend,(SP:N14.73)
11.   Zenith Bank Plc to Hold Board Meeting on January 24th, 2017
12.  Zenith Bank Plc Records Slight Strong Q3 2016 Results; Maintains Outperform Rating
13.  ZENITHBANK Declares N100.07bn PAT in Q3 2016 Result, (SP:N14.75k)
14.  Zenith Bank Plc Earnings Update - More Prudence as Bank Adopts New Impairment Model
15.   ZENITHBANK Half-Year Earnings Presentation: The key takeaways
16.  Zenith Bank Plc Earnings Miss as Loan Loss Expense Pressures PAT
17.   Zenith Bank Plc Records Group Capital Adequacy Ratio of 19% in Q2'16
18.  Zenith Bank Reports Q2 2016 Results; Significant FX-Related OCI Gains Boosted PAT
19.  Zenith Bank Plc Records Group Capital Adequacy Ratio of 19% in Q2'16
20. ZENITHBANK Declares N44.84bn PAT in Q2 16 Result Proposes 25k Interim Dividend SP N15.60k 

Related Q3 2017 Results
1.       Dangote Cement Plc. - Retaining Neutral Rating
2.      Unilever Nigeria Plc - Profits Surge on Improved Sales
3.      Dangote Cement Plc - Don’t Lose Much Sleep Over 2018
4.      Unilever Nigeria Plc. - Solid Earnings Growth; Set to Beat PAT Record
5.    Fidelity Bank Q2’17 Result - PBT and PAT Grew by 63% YoY and 255% YoY Respectively
6.      Lafarge Africa Plc. - Q3’17; A Whooping Loss After Tax
7.    FCMB Group Announces Plan to Acquire Additional Stake in Legacy Pension Managers Limited
8.     Seplat Q3 2017 Results: Net Finance Costs Up 10% YoY To $20m
9.      Unilever Nigeria Plc. - Q3’17 PAT; Strong, Amidst Surprise Increase in Finance Costs
10. Dangote Cement Plc - On Track for Strong FY Close; Quarterly Decline Worrying

Related News