Thursday, September 07, 2017 / 4:30PM / Cordros Capital
PZ released 2017FY and Q4-17 results late yesterday. For the 2017FY, revenue grew by 14.5% while PAT increased by 78.4%. The revenue N79.6 billion slightly beat our N79.1 billion estimate while the PAT of N3.3 billion is marginally below the N3.4 billion we estimated. For Q4-17 (March-May), the revenue growth of 19.1% y/y beat our 16.3% y/y estimate while the PAT growth of 370.7% y/y was ahead of our estimate of 349.2% y/y owing to the significantly lower effective tax rate (15% vs. our estimate of 32%) reported during the period. The Board recommended a final dividend of 50 kobo per share, the same as in 2016FY, but less than the 70 kobo we expected.
The Q4 result capped the impressive recovery in the group’s performance which began from the second quarter. Higher selling prices, combined with seasonality effect, accounted for the strong double-digit top-line growth the group achieved in each of the last two quarters of the year. While revenue from the Durable Electrical division contracted less (by 0.5% vs. 9.4% in 2016FY), the strong growth (22% vs. -2.3% in 2016FY) achieved by the Branded Consumer goods division (HPC) is consistent with what competitors have reported (UNILEVER’s HPC segment grew by 58% in H1-17).
During the three months period, the group reported 38.8% gross margin, the highest in all quarters of the year, and also historically. But adjusting cost of goods sold (COGS) for FX losses, as was the previous practice by the group, produced gross margin of 26.8%, 498 bps higher y/y, but lower than the margins reported in Q3-17 (27.6%) and Q2-17 (32.9%). The FX loss of N2.7 billion reported during the final quarter was the group’s second biggest in 2017FY (N4.7 billion loss was reported in Q1-17), and surprising, given the appreciation of the Naira in the secondary markets where the group said it sourced FX to settle long outstanding trade payables. For 2017FY, the group’s FX loss tripled to N8.8 billion.
Operating expenses increased by 14.9% y/y in Q4 but fell by 6.9% q/q. As a proportion of revenue, opex was lower (-60 bps y/y and -20 bps q/q). For 2017FY, opex grew by a marginal 4.7%, consistent with the benign growth recorded by most consumer goods companies in our universe in 2016FY.
From 33% average in nine months, effective tax rate (ETR) reduced to 15% in Q4, bringing the average for the 2017FY to 23.4%, much lower than the group’s 5-year average ETR of 32%. The group recognized a deferred tax credit of N1.3 billion in 2017FY (vs. N209.6 million in 2016FY).
PZ’s latest results are impressive, but given the consistency with consensus, suggesting they are already priced into the stock, we do not expect significant movement in the share price from current level. Besides, from the local investor perspective, the lower dividend proposed (equating to 60% payout vs. 5-year average of 75%) is discouraging. Based on our last TP of N14.29, at 45% discount to the current market price of N25.94, we have a SELL recommendation on the stock. Our estimates are under review.
1. PZ Cussons Nigeria Reports Q4 2017 Results - Positive Reaction by the Market Likely
2. PZ Cussons Nigeria Plc - Better-Than-Expected Recovery in Q3'17
3. PZ Cussons Nigeria Plc - Lower OPEX Supports Q3’17 Earnings
4. PZ Cussons Nigeria Reports N1.2bn FX Loss in Q3 2017 Results
5. PZ declares N1.60 bln PAT in Q3 2017 Result,(SP:N13.99k)
6. PZ Nigeria Plc FQ2 17- Strong operating performance salvage earnings
7. PZ declares N288.95 mln Loss in Q2 17 Result SP N14.25k
8. PZ Cussons Nigeria Plc to File Q2 Ended 30th Nov 2016 Financial Statements on 26th Jan 2017