Thursday 24th August 2017 12:25 PM/ Cardinalstone Research
In this report, we provide an update on Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc following the release of its impressive H1'17 results. Following adjustments to our projections, we have revised our target price (TP) to N14.45 (previous: N9.78) and retain our HOLD rating on the counter. Our price target implies a potential upside of 11.2% to current market price. Kindly see highlights below;
Further moderation in production costs anticipated as FX supply improves
Dangote Sugar Refinery, in its Q2’17 results, reported an impressive earnings growth of 159.4% QoQ despite a 0.6% QoQ decline in turnover. This was mainly the result of relatively lower production costs as the company obtained more FX for its imports (majorly raw sugar) at the official rate during the quarter.
We highlight that the exchange rate at the official market is at a 16% discount to the parallel market. Owing to this, the company’s gross margin expanded by 1903bps QoQ to 32% in Q2’17 and largely led to the 291bps YoY expansion in gross margin as well as the 131.7% YoY growth in H1’17 after-tax earnings.
With no major threat to the FX outlook in the near term, as well as the gradual accretion in FX reserves, we believe the apex bank can sustain FX supply in the official market in H2’17 which would largely drive gross margin expansion and earnings growth in FY’17.
We also expect the improvement in FX supply to offset the negative impact of sustained energy challenges arising from upsurge in the price of Low Pour Fuel Oil (LPFO). We note that energy contributes about 7% to the group’s cost of sales.
Backward integration project moving at a slow pace
We continue to reiterate that significant value in the stock will be unlocked when the company begins to produce refined sugar efficiently from locally harvested cane sugar, eliminating its exposure to the volatility in FX and international raw sugar prices.
However, the company’s backward integration project (BIP) has been moving at a slow pace. In H1’17, Savannah sugar factory produced and sold 15,805MT and 9,561MT of refined sugar from cane sugar which contributed 4.3% and 2.7% to aggregate sales and production volumes respectively in H1’17. The company continues to guide to the completion of its BIP in the next six years beginning from 2017, with current focus on two sites – Savannah (located in Adamawa) and Taraba.
For Savannah, Dangote Sugar plans to rehabilitate the refinery and expand its annual installed capacity to 100,000 MT from its current capacity of 50,000 MT while land development is ongoing in Taraba. The intention is to complete capacity expansion in Savannah in the next fifteen months and management is confident that production can ramp up having expanded its acreage area and harvested sufficient cane sugar for production.
We however expect Dangote Sugar to continue to rely on imported raw sugar in the next one to two years given that the expected volume of refined sugar from Savannah, even after capacity expansion, is only about 12% of the group’s average annual production volume.
We raise our target price to N14.45 and retain our HOLD recommendation
Given the significant outperformance of Dangote Sugar’s H1’17 earnings to our previous expectation (+81.8% deviation), we have revised our forecasts for FY’17. We raise our FY’17 turnover projection by 1.7% to N231.2 billion which implies a 36.2% YoY growth from FY’16. Our FY turnover projection is mainly driven by higher pricing (+41.0% YoY) as we expect a 4.7% YoY contraction in sales volume.
However, relative to H1’17, we expect a mild recovery in sales volume (+5.8%) in H2’17 as we envisage further cuts to refined sugar prices given the moderation in productions costs. Following improved macroeconomic conditions and FX supply, management noted an uptick in production for some of its industrial consumers which also is positive for volume in H2’17.
Given the cost of sales surprise (-16% deviation from our H1’17 estimate), we cut our FY’17 cost of sales projection by 4.7% to N177.4 billion and project FY’17 margin at 23.3% (FY’16: 13.5%). Our lower cost of sales projection is driven by the company’s ability to source more of its FX requirement from the interbank than the parallel market which was previously its main source. Given the above, we project a 134.1% growth in FY’17 earnings to N33.7 billion (FY’16: N14.4 billion) and raise our target price on Dangote Sugar to N14.45 (previous: N9.78). Our target price implies an 11.2% potential upside from current market price thus, we retain our HOLD rating on the counter.
1. Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc - Bet the Ranch?
4. Dangote Sugar Refinery Q1 2017 Sales of N59.5bn Grew by 83% YoY
5. Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc - Update After Speaking with Management
6. DANGSUGAR Declares N14.40 billion PAT in 2016 Audited Result,(SP:N0.50k)
7. Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc - Recommendation Upgraded
8. Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc - Production costs surge, caps earnings growth
9. DANGSUGAR Declares N10.12billion PAT in Q3 2016 Result SP N6.25k
10. Increase in Selling Price to Cushion Dangote Sugar Plc Cost Pressures
11. Dangote Sugar Refinery’s Rising costs Weigh on Growth Outlook
12. DANGSUGAR Declares N7.38billion PAT in Q2 2016 Result SP N7.00k
13. Dangote Sugar Refinery Plc Q2 16 - Interest savings on debt pay-down saves the day
14. Dangote Sugar Refinery Operating Expenses Grow by 28% YoY in Q2'16
15. Dangote Sugar Records N70.5bn Revenue in Q2’16
16. DANGSUGAR Declares N3.34billion PAT in Q1 2016 Result SP N5.50k