DANGSUGAR: Weaker volumes behind lukewarm outlook; Shares Rated NEUTRAL


Wednesday, November 25, 2015 09:54AM / FBNQuest Research   
Significant cuts to our earnings forecasts:

Dangote Sugar Refinery’s (DSR) Q3 2015 results came in slightly behind our estimates. A negative surprise on the topline was partially offset by opex coming in –15% behind our N1.5bn estimate.

Looking ahead, we have made slight cuts to our sales forecast for the year, largely to reflect lower production volumes and persistent distribution challenges. We expect a capacity utilisation rate of around 50% for the Lagos refinery in 2015E, compared with c.60% in each of the previous two years.

We have made no changes to our average finished sugar price estimate for 2015E of N6,600/kg as we believe it already reflects DSR’s recent sugar price reduction. As such, we have cut our EPS forecasts by around 2% on average over the 2015-16E period.

Our new price target of N7.4 is up by 10% mainly because we have lowered our risk-free rate assumption by 250bps to 13% to reflect the contraction in FGN bond yields. Our new target implies a potential upside of 19.5% from current levels.

DSR shares are trading on a 2015E P/E multiple of 6.4x for an 11% growth in EPS in 2016E. Ytd, DSR shares have declined -2.4%, outperforming the NSE ASI’s by around 18%. We retain our Neutral rating on the stock.

Q3 PBT and PAT up 19% y/y and 33% respectively:
While sales declined by 9% y/y to N21.9bn, PBT and PAT were both up by 19% y/y and 33% y/y respectively. A 750bp y/y gross margin expansion to 27.7% and a flattish y/y opex more than offset the topline decline and a significant y/y rise in finance charges.

Sequentially, sales, PBT and PAT all declined by 23% q/q, 26% q/q and 22% q/q respectively. This time around, the topline decline and a 37% q/q rise in opex more than offset a 255bp q/q expansion in gross margin. Compared with our estimates, sales and PAT came in 13% and 7% behind of our forecasts respectively.

Raw sugar prices increasingly less supportive:

We forecast sales and EPS of N96.0bn and N0.97 in 2015E. Both estimates are flattish y/y. We believe topline growth is likely to be hindered by comparatively lower y/y sales volumes, despite higher prices on average this year.


In Q4, we expect to see a moderate q/q contraction in gross margin (to 22.7%) given the reduction in sugar prices to N5,750 per 50kg bag from N8,000 and rising raw sugar prices (a key raw material), which were up 30% over the last three months.


Management explained on its Q3 earnings conference call that price reductions are needed to fend off increasing smuggling activity.

Click Here to Download Full Report


Related News

1.       Dangote Sugar Sustains bottom-line growth despite low sales in Q3 15

2.      Dangote Sugar grows PAT by 2.07 as revenue down by 1.02 in Q3 15

3.      DANGSUGAR Moving in an uptrend just buy it

4.      DANGSUGAR Investing for Sustainable Growth FSDH Places a BUY

5.      DANGSUGAR Better-than-expected Q2 2015

6.      DANGSUGAR declares N6.31billion PAT in Q2'15 result,(SP:N6.00k)

7.      DANGSUGAR Roller coaster moves are going on

8.     DANGSUGAR Bulls are generating bullish signal at an initial stage

9.      DANGSUGAR Soft raw sugar prices save the day

10.  4. DANGSUGAR Records N2.4 billion PAT IN Q1 2015 Group Revenue Drops by 13

11.   5. DANGSUGAR Rated NEUTRAL After the Release of Q1 2015 Result Sales PBT PAT All Down YoY 

Related News