Very Heavy Debt Burdens for Most States


Friday, May 14, 2021 / 11:23 AM / By FBNQuest Research / Header Image Credit: FBNQuest 


The external debt of state governments is contracted on non-market terms with official creditors. It has to be approved in advance by federal agencies such as the DMO, and is heavily skewed towards those states favoured for their policy, governance and operational management by the donor community. Lagos State naturally tops the list due to its capacity to generate revenue, and its efforts to provide transport and other services to its population. Kaduna and the other states featuring in our chart can be associated with current and/or previous governors with developmental agendas. The remaining 31 states plus the federal capital territory were externally indebted at end-2020 to the tune of USD2.14bn, implying an average of less than USD70m per state. The total debt of the subnational rose by 4.6% y/y from USD4.56bn at end-2019.


Their total external indebtedness of USD4.77bn was 93% due to multilateral creditors (principally the World Bank and African Development Bank groups). The Agence francaise de developpement, the French state development bank, accounts for most of the bilateral lending of USD310m, disbursing to eleven different states.


The domestic debt of the states is larger, amounting to the equivalent of USD10.20bn at end-2020 and more widely distributed. Lagos again tops the table but with a far smaller share of 12.2% of the total.  The other states heading the league tend to be oil producers such as Delta and Rivers.


The domestic debt stock was growing rapidly until the first Buhari administration, which introduced controls on new commitments and arranged a swap of states' bank borrowings for FGN long bonds. The growth slowed to 1.9% y/y in 2020.


Taking the external and domestic debt together, Lagos was the most indebted at end-2020 (USD2.65bn), followed by three in the USD650m-USD750m range (Delta, Kaduna and Rivers).


Federal agencies are containing the growth of subnational debt for reasons of best practice. They know that the repayment capacity of most states has shrunk in the past decade and that the monthly payout by the Federation Account Allocation Committee falls well short of states' spending in aggregate (Good Morning Nigeria, 30 April 2021).


External debt of state governments, Dec '20 (% shares)                    Total USD4.77bn

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Sources: Debt Management Office (DMO); FBNQuest Capital Research

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News on Debts

  1. Modest Burden of External Debt Service in Q4 2020
  2. A Rise in Domestic Debt Service in Q4 2020
  3. 38.60% of Nigeria's Total Public Debt Was External in Q4 2020 - NBS
  4. Q4 2020 External Debt Data: World Bank Heads the FGN's External Creditor List
  5. A Modest Increase in FGN Domestic Debt in Q4 2020
  6. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood at N32.92trn as of December 31, 2020 - DMO
  7. FGN's Domestic Debt Service on a Plateau, Totalled N604bn in Q3 2020
  8. A Small Rise in the FGN's Domestic Debt in Q3 2020
  9. Nigeria's Public Debt Stock as of September 30, 2020 Stood at N32.22trn
  10. External Debt Service Under Control 
  11. New Issuance, New Debt Service 
  12. External Debt Almost Two-thirds Concessionary 
  13. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N31.01trn in Q2 2020 - NBS 
  14. Nigeria's Public Debt Stock Stood At N31.01trn As of June 2020 
  15. External Debt Stock Flat in Q1 2020 
  16. Q1 2020: Debt Service Settled on a Plateau 
  17. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N28.63trn in Q1 2020 - NBS 
  18. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N27.40trn in Q4 2019 - NBS 
  19. Nigeria's Rising Debt Burden and How to Boost Revenue 
  20. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N26.14trn in Q3 2019 - NBS 
  21. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N25.70trn in Q2 2019 - NBS 
  22. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood At N24.97trn in Q1 2019 - NBS 
  23. DMO Releases Q1 2019 Public Debt Data - Marginal Increase of 2.3% in Total Public Debt Recorded 
  24. DMO Releases Public Debt Data for December 2018 
  25. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stock Stood At $73.21bn or N22.43trn in Q3 2018 
  26. DMO Releases Public Debt Data for June 2018; FGN Domestic Debt Declines 
  27. Public Debt Vulnerable to Exchange Rate Movements 
  28. DMO Publishes Q1 2018 Debt Data; Total Public Debt Stood At N22.71trn or US$74.28bn 
  29. Total Public Debt as at December 31, 2017 Represents 18.20% of Nigeria's GDP for 2017 - DMO 
  30. Nigerian Public Debt - A Comparative Analysis 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd. 


Related News on State and Local Govts

  1. Book of States 2020: Vast Resources, Low Industrial Development
  2. 2020 IGR Report: Urgent Need to Bolster States' IGR
  3. Improving IGR: A Call for Action
  4. NIPC Publishes Book of States 2020
  5. N1.31trn Generated as IGR in 2020 - NBS
  6. Actual Expenditure of All 36 States Grew by 2.73% to N5.26trn in 2019 Fiscal Year
  7. Ogun State Debt Figures - Understanding the Facts, Fiction and Black Spots
  8. Ehingbeti Economic Summit 2021: The Lagos of Our Dream
  9. 8th Ehingbetti Summit: Lagos as An Accelerator; A Smart City's Destiny
  10. Ogun State: 52 Weeks of Building Our Future Together
  11. Communique - Meeting of the SW Governors, MACBAN and Security Agencies
  12. IOD Forum: Governor Sanwo-Olu Highlights US$2bn PPP Opportunities in Lagos
  13. How the Lagos T.H.E.M.E Agenda Will Drive Industrialization - Gbenga Omotosho
  14. Lagos State Explains its 2021 Budget of "Rekindled Hope" to Media Executives
  15. 2021 Budget: Lagos to Raise N100bn Debt Through the Capital Market to Finance Development
  16. FAAC Payout Well Below Most States' Needs
  17. LASG Reviews 2021 Budget; Builds on the T.H.E.M.E Agenda
  18. BudgIT Publishes 2020 Revised State of States Reports, Measure Epidemic Preparedness of States
  19. Cardoso Leads Eight-Man Team for Lagos Recovery Efforts
  20. Fiscal Ill-health of Most States


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News