25, 2019 06:25PM / ARM Research / Header Image Credit: Wise Owl
In our H1 19 strategy report, we had estimated fiscal deficit over 2019 to print at N2.9 trillion – from our revenue expectation of N4.4 trillion and expenditure of N7.2 trillion – which basically formed our domestic borrowing expectation of N1.4 trillion after adjusting for CBN part funding of 34% of the projected domestic borrowing N2.1 trillion. Coming into 2019, actual fiscal deficit in the first five months of 2019 printed at N825 billion (-50% YoY) Reflecting the lag in FG’s retained revenue relative to budget implementation. However, FG borrowed just N371.8 between January and May, representing 45.1% of the total deficit, with no foreign borrowings over the period. For us, we believe the excess deficit of N426.8 billion was funded by the CBN similar to the prior year. To clarify, total overdraft claims on FGN increased by N615.1 billion between December 2018 and April 2019 – which translates to 15.8% of 2018 actual FGN revenue. That said, total overdraft claims on FG now prints at N6.0 trillion as at April.
Over 2019, we expect federally collected revenue to print at N4.2 trillion (53% lower than budget projections), which is 6% higher than the prior year. Our estimate is based on expected average crude oil price of $62.31/bbl. and our forecast crude oil production of 2.04mbpd, which resulted in oil revenue of N1.8 trillion (budget estimate of N3.7 trillion). On non-oil revenue, following the kick-off of the divestment process of FG’s equity stake in JV oil assets in 2018, we see some room for completion during the year, albeit at a lower valuation. With our modelled budget implementation of 89%, we estimate that fiscal deficit could range between N3.0 trillion and N4.8 trillion with our base case of N3.7 trillion. In terms of financing, on the sale & privatization of government assets where FG expects N210 billion, we forecast no sale and project foreign borrowing of $2.2 billion (N803 billion) over the second half of the year. With the balance of N1.8 funded by the CBN as in the prior year.
Approved 2019 Budget: Much of the same
In a less confrontational exercise than usual, the National Assembly passed the 2019 budget in May with the President assenting to the appropriation bill the same month. Compared to the proposed outlay of N8.83 trillion submitted to the National Assembly in December 2018, the approved budget was increased by N80.3 billion to N8.91 trillion due to an upward review of recurrent non-debt expenditure by N17.4 billion, capital spending by N63.3 billion, statutory transfers by N9.7 billion. However, we saw a N10 billion cutback in provision for sinking fund. Clearly, the increase in capital expenditure largely emanated from adjustments made on capital allocations to top 12 MDAs and increase related constituency projects. On statutory transfer, the breakdown reveals an increase of N5 billion to NDDC1, N1.5 billion to UBE, N3 billion to the National Assembly and N0.199 billion to the Public Complaints Commission.
On revenue, compared to prior years, National Assembly left all oil revenue assumptions unchanged, translating to a projected revenue of N3.7 trillion. On the other hand, overall non-oil revenue estimate was increased by N31.5 billion to N3.3 trillion essentially reflecting upward adjustments to receipts from Company Income Tax (N14 billion to N813.4 billion) and Custom Revenue (N8.3 billion to N310.9 billion). Furthermore, estimates for independent revenue was also increased by N6.5 billion to N631 billion, while the Federation account levies and special accounts was increased by N2.82 billion to N64 billion. On balance, reflecting the higher adjustments to expenditure compared to the revenue estimates, fiscal deficit increased by N58.9 billion to N1.92 trillion. However, reflecting inconsistency on the part of the legislature on the financing of the deficit, planned borrowings was revised lower by N44 billion to N1.61 trillion, which coupled with the N210 billion projected privatization proceeds, left the approved budget with a financing gap of N102.8 billion.
Lower oil prices underpin drag FG receipts
In our H1 2019 Nigeria Strategy Report (See Report: Nigerian Fiscal: More strain on FG finances), we had expressed concerns about the overly optimistic nature of FG’s revenue projections, which was little changed from the approved appropriation bill. Over the first five months of 2019, actual federally retained revenue of N1.5 trillion fell short of prorated budget estimate by 49% and below same period in the prior year by 11.3%. The shortfall emanated largely from lower than projected oil and non-oil receipts. On oil revenue, provided breakdown by CBN showed actual oil receipts fell short of expectation by 28% due to lower than anticipated crude-oil and gas exports, domestic crude oil and gas sales, and PPT/Royalties. Relative to FG’s projections, the slow-down in constituents of oil receipt largely reflects sizable shortfall in crude oil production (~1.94mbpd average) as prices were higher over the review period. However, when compared to the prior year, the decline in oil receipts largely reflects lower prices over 2019, which averaged $67.20/barrel compared to average over the same period of 2018 of $70.20/barrel. On the non-oil leg, the decline relative to the prior year (and prorated budget estimate) emanated from shortfalls in receipt from independent revenue, corporate income tax and other revenue.
On expenditure, reflecting the lower receipts relative to the prior year, budget implementation printed at 62.6% (vs. 88.3% in 5M 18). FGN’s spend over the review period printed at N2.3 trillion with recurrent expenditure (N1.63 trillion) accounting for 70% of total spend, 26% was disbursed to meet capital expenditure (N607 billion), while the balance of N90 billion was allocated to statutory transfers. Notably, the CAPEX spend reflects funds allocated to the completion of outstanding 2018 capital projects as the 2019 capital spend commenced after the assent of the appropriation bill.
Reflecting the lag in FG’s retained revenue relative to budget implementation, fiscal deficit amounted to N825 billion (-50% YoY) above N799 billion allotted in the budget for the period. However, FG borrowed just N371.8 between January and May, representing 45.1% of the total deficit, with no foreign borrowings over the period. For us, we believe the excess deficit of N426.8 billion was funded by the CBN similar to what was done in the prior year. To clarify, the law allows FG to fund its expenses through unorthodox sources, such as overdraft from the CBN which gives room for the government to receive up to 5% of the prior years’ actual revenue. Going by CBN’s data, total overdraft claims on FGN increased by N615.1 billion between December 2018 and April 2019 – which translates to 15.8% of 2018 actual FGN revenue. That said, total overdraft claims on FG now prints at N6.0 trillion as at April.
Improved FGN receipt, but short of projection
Coming into 2019, the free fall in crude oil prices amidst global idiosyncrasies had informed our expectation of average crude oil price of $55.95/bbl. and production of 2.07mbpd, guiding our projected oil receipts of N2 trillion (Budget estimate: N3.69trillion). While crude oil prices over the first half of the year came ahead of our estimate at $66.06/bbl., average crude oil production fell short of estimate at 1.96mbpd to offset the impact of higher prices. Going into the rest of the year, we have adjusted our base FGN oil revenue estimate slightly lower to N1.8 trillion, reflecting a downward adjustment to production and FG’s share of overall oil revenue. However, we increased our estimate for average crude oil prices to $62.3/bbl.
In line with historical trend, we expect non-oil receipts to grossly underperform budget estimates over 2019 due to ambitious targets set by the FG and the National Assembly. However, relative to our estimate earlier in the year, total non-oil receipt is expected to come in slightly higher at N2.41 trillion (previously: N2.32 trillion). The adjustment emanated largely from the increase in our projected receipts from custom/excise duties following the increase in exchange rate for Customs duty from N306/$ to N326/$ earlier in June. Albeit, the impact was muted by the downward revision of our projected Other Revenue estimate to N746 billion which includes the N500 billion estimated income from divestment of FG’s equity stake in JV oil assets. While we maintain our bullishness on CIT following our expectation of improved performance of the non-oil sector and higher consumption in 2019, the upward review by the National Assembly suggests shortfall of 16.1% compared to our estimates. Combined with oil receipts, we estimate federally collected revenue to print at N4.2 trillion for 2019 (53% lower than budget projections), which is 6% higher than the prior year.
Elsewhere on expenditure, assuming 100% implementation of recurrent expenditure, which typically runs January – December and much lower capital expenditure of 58% (5-year average of 59%, and FY 18 of 57%), which runs one year from the month of budget approval, we assume 89% budget implementation. Thus, we estimate total expenditure of N7.91 trillion in 2019, which overlaid on our projected revenue scenarios suggests that the fiscal deficit could range between N3.0 trillion and N4.8 trillion.
CBN backdoor financing will constrain local borrowing
In financing its proposed fiscal deficit of N1.9 trillion, the FG plans to improve on its optimal debt mix. The expectation is to fund the sum of N1.6 trillion via domestic and foreign borrowing in the ratio mix of 50:50, while the excess of N210 billion would be funded from the privatization of some non-oil assets by the Bureau of Public Enterprises (BPE). However, we believe the balance of N1.8 trillion in our estimate will largely be funded by the CBN considering the increase in CBN overdraft to the FGN over the first five months of the year.
Recall, following the meager borrowings over 2018 of N290 billion, total overdraft extended by the apex bank amounted to N2.1 trillion, which helped support overall deficit (N3.8 trillion) during the year. While actual guidance on the drawdown from the CBN wallet is not provided, we assumed two scenarios; 1) we annualized the overdraft from the CBN between the first five months which summed to N1.8 trillion, and 2) we assumed the same level over 2018. Overall, we believe actual borrowings from the capital market could be much lower than approved in the 2019 budget. Additionally, we played out different scenarios in the table below to forecast the potential size of domestic paper issue using our estimated fiscal deficit. Overall, we estimate that to finance the budget, the net debt issue could range between N622 billion and N1.1 trillion with the range sizably higher than 2018 net issuance of N290 billion. In sum, our scenario analysis guides to a higher domestic borrowing relative to 2018.
Related News from ARM’s H2 2019 Nigeria Strategy Report
Related News from ARM’s H1 2019 Nigeria Strategy Report
Research 234 (1) 2701653 firstname.lastname@example.org
Related News from ARM’s H2 2018 Nigeria Strategy Report
2. NSR H2 2018 (14) - Fixed Income: Have Yields hit the bottom?
3. NSR H2 2018 (13) - Monetary Policy: A Classic Catch-22, Where will the Balance Tilt?
4. NSR H2 2018 (12)- Nigerian Inflation: Approaching an Inflection Point
5. NSR H2 2018 (11)- Currency: The Battle for Naira Stability
6. NSR H2 2018 (10)- Balance of Payment: CA Surplus Recycled Through Record Portfolio Outflows
7. NSR H2 2018 (9)- Growth to Run Above 2%, But Nearing a Cyclical Peak
9. NSR H2 2018 (7) - Pension: Multi-fund - Will Variable Assets Blow-Up or Blow Over?
13. NSR H2 2018 (3) - Crude Oil: Stability Gains Ground in Titans' Tug of War