PPPRA: The LPG Onslaught

Oil & Gas
Proshare - Facebook Proshare - Twitter Proshare - Linked In Proshare - WhatsApp

Tuesday, March 09 2021   /05:00 AM / By Proshare Research/ Header Image Credit: EcoGraphics

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Stakeholders in the gas industry have lamented the increased burden caused by the actions of the PPPRA. The PPPRA is charged with the responsibility of monitoring, and regulating the supply and distribution, and determining prices. The major problem that these stakeholders have with the PPPRA is that the administration cost which it charges distorts operational efficiency and pricing. They argue that since the government had embarked on the full deregulation of the gas sector there is no moral justification for the administration cost charged by PPRA. Furthermore, it is argued that the PPPRA is fully funded by the Federal government and does not provide any service that warrants the administrative cost imposed by the PPPRA.


The allegedly unwarranted charges by the PPPRA make it expedient to understand the regulatory and pricing mechanism in other global jurisdictions. Countries that are interested in deepening the gas industry, for example, Australia ensure that the regulatory framework is transparent and attractive to investors, hence the fast-paced growth of the industry in that country.


Understanding Best Practices and Pricing

Understanding the best practices and prices of gas is vital to the growth of the sector. The impact of government regulations has had a major impact on the gas sector in Nigeria. Making the gas sector attractive and competitive would encourage the flow of foreign investment to the industry. The pro-market regulation of the gas industry would facilitate the optimization of the industry's value chains. On the other hand, the implementation of non-market-friendly regulatory order would discourage the inflow of foreign investment into the gas industry, disrupting the full utilization of the gas value chain. There are many byproducts of gas not fully tapped, hence, the need for government-friendly regulations. Natural gas can be used as fuel in transportation, industries, commercial buildings, or residences. Natural gas can serve as a substitute for PMS which is more costly e.g., the Federal government proposed its plan to convert PMS cars to gas cars. Furthermore, natural gas can be used as a feedstock for various other industrial plants, such as fertilizer plants, methanol plants, petrochemical plants, and gas-to-liquids plants (see Illustration 8).




Illustration 8: Natural Gas: Living in a World of Changes

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Poor gas pricing will affect the gas ecosystem which consists of producers, local distribution companies, marketers, on-system, and off-system users. Investors in the gas sector understandably worry about making profits and expanding their reach. Therefore, experts believe that it is important that policies should be enacted that would encourage a flow of fresh investors into the local market (see Illustration 9).


Illustration 9: Gas and its Business Family

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Along each value chain of the gas industry, there are benefits and potentials to the Nigerian economies. Deepening the gas value chain would attract more investment into the country. Countries such as Australia, China, France, and Russia have been able to deepen their value chains and attract a growing number of investments to their economies (see Illustration 10).




Illustration 10: LNG; Along a Chain of Values

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



The Case for Appropriate Pricing

In determining the appropriate price of gas, it is pertinent to factor-in the demand and supply for gas and the other drivers of price in the gas market. Key drivers of natural gas supply include unconventional development, new pipelines, floating technologies, new LNG capacity, and national-level policies that affect supply.  Key drivers of current global demand are Asian economic growth and national-level policies that affect demand.  Policies that affect natural and liquified petroleum gas supply and demand generally have roots in environmental, safety, and energy security objectives (see Illustration 11). 




Illustration 11: LPG; The Value Pipeline in Transition

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Gas Pricing

Two major gas pricing mechanisms are very common. They include the netback pricing and market price. In the case of the netback pricing mechanism, the gas price is defined by other prices, mainly those from substitutes like fuel oil. The netback pricing principle is also known as the top-down approach, where the gas price is derived from other energy sources. The price reflects substitution relationships between gas and comparable fuels like gas oil, fuel oil, or, less commonly, coal and electricity. If fixed cost components like taxes or regulated tariffs along the value chain are subtracted, a margin for the producer remains. Based on the substitute price, this margin could be higher or lower and, in some situations, also negative. The price is set by a formula that is fixed in a very complex long-term contract. The formula is subject to regular renegotiations to guarantee that the formula still reflects the actual market development allows a margin sharing of the two contract parties along the value chain.


On the other hand, the market price which is the second pricing mechanism is determined by the free market forces of demand and supply. This pricing mechanism is also known as the bottom-up approach as the cost components of the gas itself are the drivers of the gas price and not the prices of its substitutes. Asides from fixed and regulated components, this approach also takes into consideration production costs which have a significant impact on the prices (see Illustration 12). 


Illustration 12: The Gas Price; Making Market Mechanism Count

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Gas Pricing in Selected Countries

Different economies adopt varying pricing mechanisms depending on which suites the market best. This section will examine the pricing mechanism adopted in various economies.


US Market

Gas pricing mechanism development in the US could be traced to the liquids wholesale market, with exchange-traded futures contracts to support pricing mechanism not vulnerable to any form of influences and was more reflective of a market mechanism.


Historically, natural gas prices were fixed by the government, but in 1992, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission (FERC) issued its Order 636. Prices were deregulated and interstate natural gas pipeline companies were required to split-off any nonregulated merchant (sales) functions from their regulated transportation functions. The separation of gas contract pricing and transportation contract pricing meant that exchange-traded gas contracts, based on Henry Hub and other secondary hubs, were established, and the industry moved to market-based indices for pricing purposes.


The European Market

In Europe, a similar trend was first established in the UK, following gas market deregulation in the mid-1990s, and the emergence of National Balancing Point (NBP) pricing, which, though like Henry Hub, is not a physical place. In Continental Europe, the so-called Title Transfer Facility (TTF) has now become an equally dependable mechanism for long-term pricing, though Southern Europe is still transitioning to a mechanism of gas-on-gas pricing, as new hubs start to emerge.


The Asia-Pacific Market

The first signs that a new pricing basis was emerging for the Asia-Pacific region occurred in the early 2010s with the signing of Henry Hub-based LNG tolling contracts. At the time, buying gas in the U.S. and paying a tolling fee to put it through one of the emerging LNG liquefaction facilities, represented a lower landed price in Japan and other SE Asian countries, compared to traditionally oil-priced gas. Several attempts are being made to establish a pricing index for the Asia-Pacific market, including the so-called JKM index (Japan-Korea-Marker) and the Singapore Gas Exchange (SGX) spot price index known as SLiNG, which is intended to represent an exchange-traded futures market for LNG based on gas being traded at or around the Singapore LNG facilities.


Current Developments

The LNG sector has been relatively slow to move away from oil-based pricing. There are many reasons for this, but the main brake on pricing change for LNG has been the lack of availability of a reliable, transparent pricing reference for gas, like Henry Hub or NBP, in the Asia-Pacific region, which accounts for about two-thirds of LNG consumption. The other feature of LNG, compared to pipeline gas, is that it is bought and sold in single ship-borne cargoes, instead of being commingled within a pipeline system, and this too has tended to slow down the development of gas-on-gas mechanisms.


In Europe, over the last decade, most of the traded gas has now migrated from oil-based to gas on gas-based pricing, and some commentators believe that gas-on-gas-based pricing will gradually replace oil-based index pricing, particularly as new LNG projects bring additional LNG into the global markets.


An increasing number of African countries are considering moving to LNG imports or establishing relatively smaller-scale projects. Because these are under development and/or negotiations, no pricing has been established yet.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Downloadable Version of Memo to the Market: PPPRA and the Nigerian Gas Market, Avoiding a Robinhood

1.   Full Report: Memo to the Market: PPPRA and the Nigerian Gas Market, Avoiding a Robinhood - Mar 02, 2021

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News

1.      Gas Market Deregulation: The Nuts and Bolts

2.     The PIB and the Gas Sector - Shaping a New Model

3.     The Nigerian Gas Market: The LPG Mind Shift

4.     The New Gas Reality

5.     PPPRA and the Nigerian Gas Market: Avoiding a Robinhood

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related Link

1.      NLPGA v PPPRA - An Originating Summons in the Federal High Court of Nigeria Holden at Lagos  - Jan, 2021

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related Videos

1.      Why Full Deregulation is Vital for Nigeria's Oil and Gas Sector

2.     Privatization of NNPC Refineries, Will Attract More Investments into the Oil and Gas Industry - Tominiyi Owolabi

3.     Decades of Nigeria's Oil and Gas Sector: Way Forward

4.     Why Gas Should be Leveraged as A Pivot for Diversifying Nigeria's Revenue - Bambo Ibidapo-Obe

5.     How Oil and Gas Zones can Support Nigeria's Economic Growth

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News - PMS Pricing

1.      Subsidy Removal and Cost-Reflective Tariff: Tough Decisions to be Made

2.     Possible Increase in PMS Price, Stakeholders Call for Fixing of the Non-Functional Refineries

3.     Uncertainty Over PMS Price - A Clear Indication Inflation Concerns Could Linger

4.     Commencement of Dangote Refinery's Production Would Improve Nigeria's Current Account Balance

5.     FG Inaugurates Technical Committee On PMS Pricing Framework

6.     FG: Dangote Refinery Will Sell Petrol at International Price

7.     Is PMS Price Deregulation for Real or a Mirage?

8.     NLC Communicates the Decision of Its CWC on Hike in PMS Pump Price and Electricity Tariff

9.     PPMC Increases Ex-depot Price of PMS to N151.56 per Litre

10.  Policy Directions on PMS, Tariff Hike, Gas and Stamp Duties and Implications on Households

11.   PPPRA Releases Advised Price for PMS for the Month of July 2020; Raises Pump Price to N140

12.  PPPRA Removes Existing PMS Price Cap; Commences Market Based Pricing Regime

13.  The Conundrum in the Retail Pricing of PMS

14.  Petrol: An End to the Subsidy Regime?

15.  The Deregulation Farce; What's The Way Forward?


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News - Previous Oilprice Intelligence Report 

1.      Brent Crude Holds Gains Above $65 - OIR 230221

2.     Brent Crude Oil Price Falls Back Below $64 - OIR 190221

3.     How Much Higher Can Oil Prices Go? - OIR 120221

4.     Bullish Sentiment Takes Over Oil Markets - OIR 090221

5.     Brent Crude Surges Towards $60 - OIR 050221

6.     Oil Prices Hit 1-Year High - OIR 020221

7.     Oil Prices Hit 1-Year High - OIR 020221

8.     New Vaccine Hopes Boost Oil Prices - OIR 260121

9.     Oil Price Rally Paused By Chinese COVID Concerns - OIR 260121

10.  Energy Shares Plunge as Oil Rally Halts - OIR 220121

11.   Oil Demand Fears Continue to Weigh on Markets - OIR 190121


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

CMOs/Reports on Oil and Gas Sector

1.      Oil and Gas: Working the New Normal in the Time of a Pandemic

2.     The Nigerian Oil and Gas Industry Update: Urgent Need for Reforms

3.     Oil and Gas Update: Downstream Oil and Gas at a Crossroads

4.     Nigerian Oil and Gas Industry Update

5.     Oil and Gas Sector Records 1 Gainer to 7 Losers; Index Dipped By -19.83% YTD

6.     NCM2020 (20) - Oil and Gas Sector - SEPLAT Tops On EPS and PAT Margin As Mobil Tops on ROE

7.     Nigerian Oil And Gas Sector- Q3 2019 Earnings Preview

8.     The Oil Market, 2020 Black Swan, and A Third Virus Wave 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News on Oil and Gas Companies Latest Results

1.      CONOIL Declares N1.1bn PAT in Q3 2020 Results, (SP:N19.05k)

2.     JAPAULOIL Declares N91m PAT in Q3 2020 Result, (SP:N1.11k)

3.     ETERNA Declares N194m PAT in Q3 2020 Unaudited Results, (SP:N5.00K)

4.     Ardova Plc Declares N1.9bn PAT in Q3 2020 Result, (SP:N12.65k)

5.     SEPLAT Declares N33.7bn Loss in Q3 2020 Results, Proposes $0.05 Interim Dividend; (SP:N420.00k)

6.     MRS Declares N881m Loss in Q3 2020 Results, (SP:N12.45k)

7.     TOTAL Declares N500m PAT in Q3 2020 Results, (SP:N112.20k)

8.     RAKUNITY declares N37m Loss in Q3 2020 Unaudited Results, (SP:N0.50k)

9.     OANDO Notifies of Delay in the Publication of its Q3 2020 Financials

10.  OANDO Declares N13.06bn PAT in Q3 2019 Results (SP:N3.40k)


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News on PIB

1.      NNRC Encourages NASS to Prioritize The PIB

2.     Inside Nigeria's 2020 Petroleum Industry Bill

3.       PIB Will Ensure Nigerians Benefit Optimally from Oil and Gas Resources - Ahmed Lawan

4.     PIB: Will the Jinx be Broken This Time Around?

5.     Petroleum Industry Bill - Is There Light At The End of The Tunnel?

6.     Nigeria to Draft Petroleum Industry Bill from Scratch

7.     FG Explains Why Presidential Assent Was Withheld For Petroleum Industry Governance Bill

8.     House of Representatives Passes Petroleum Industry Governance Bill

9.     Senate Passed Petroleum Industry Governance Bill

10.  Analysing the Petroleum Industry Bill

11.   Petroleum Industry Bill - Senate To Receive Final Report on PIGB April 25

12.  Bukola Saraki's Remarks at Petroleum Industry Bill Public Hearing

13.  The New Petroleum Industry Bill and Taxation of Petroleum Products in Nigeria

14.  FG may effect changes in Petroleum Industry Bill

15.  PIB Will Be An Enabler For Increased Investments In The Oil and Gas Sector - Bambo Ibidapo-Obe

16.  Power Sector: How PIB/Deregulation considerations dampens interest in mini refineries


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News