FGN Borrowing from the CBN - Curse or Blessing?

Proshare

Friday, April 30, 2021 / 08:28 AM / by FDC Limited / Header Image Credit: Tribune


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


The standard definition of a central bank is that it is the bankers' bank and the bank to the government. Therefore, the central bank is often obliged to provide financial support to the government to meet its financing needs. Central bank lending to their host governments are usually funded by selling of government paper directly or issued on behalf of the government. In some cases, a government's expenditure is funded by ways and means advances, which grants the government an overdraft by means of direct monetary financing.

 

Since the oil price shock of 2014-2016, the Nigerian government has often relied on borrowings from the Central Bank to plug its revenue shortfalls. The practice has, however, become increasingly worrisome due to the inflationary risks associated and the delayed repayment of the loans.

 

In January 2021, international ratings agency, Fitch Ratings, warned that continual dependence on central bank lending could undermine the stability of the Nigerian economy. Notwithstanding, the CBN has insisted on sustained credit financing to the government. While the minister of finance recently affirmed the need to reduce reliance on central bank lending, the CBN's commitment to uphold the practice poses a fundamental threat to investor confidence and the stability of the economy. The Nigerian government's debt at the CBN was estimated at N13.2 trillion (8.6% of GDP) as of September 2020 and headline inflation is already at a more than four-year high of 18.17%.

 

Related Link: Nigeria's Deficit Monetisation May Raise Macro-Stability Risks - Jan 20, 2021

 

Impact of Central Bank lending on the Economy

Central bank lending to the government is usually necessitated by fiscal gaps and the need to support economic recovery efforts. This is different from intervention lending for developmental initiatives in the country such as the anchor borrowers programme. CBN's lending to the government is targeted at reducing the fiscal pressures of the government at times of significant revenue shortfalls. Nigeria's fiscal revenue has been susceptible to swings due to peaks and troughs in the global price of oil. For example in 2016, the global economy recorded a huge slump in oil prices, which plunged below $30pb in January 2016. This weighed significantly on country's fiscal and external balances resulting in a recession in 2016. The country also continues to face a rising fis-cal deficit resulting in a surge in government borrowing, both domestic and external. Nigeria's debt to GDP ratio rose to 34.98% in 2020 from 29.10% in 2019.6 Fiscal deficit is also estimated at 3.6% of GDP (N5.6trn) in the 2021 budget, higher than the 3% benchmark in the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2007.

 

According to the CBN, the direct impact of credit financing from the Central Bank is the surge in money supply, which typically results in price and exchange rate instability.8 Hence, the CBN's commitment to continue to finance the government undermines its core monetary responsibili-ties. Although the government has announced plans to securitize its debt at the CBN, this could result in an increase in its debt service costs, which will weigh on its credit rating. Fitch retained its credit rating for Nigeria at 'B' with a stable outlook on March 19 but highlighted sustained central bank lending as one of the potential threats to the country's rating.9 In addition, continual reliance on CBN financing could encourage fiscal complacency in the implementation of revenue genera-tion reforms by the government.

 

Lessons from Zimbabwe

The Zimbabwean government resorted to central bank financing after sanctions from the international community in 2001. The sanctions were prompted by the contentious land reform program initiated by the then president, late Robert Mugabe, in 2000. The program encouraged black farmers to reclaim their farmlands from white commercial farmers. The US, in reaction, imposed sanctions on the economy restricting support for multilateral financing to Zimbabwe. The country therefore relied on monetary financing to meet its fiscal obligations, which led to a spike in its inflation rate to as high as 79.6 billion percent in November 2008, the second-highest case of hyperinflation on record.10 Although the inflation rate has since reduced, Zimbabwe is still struggling with a three-digit inflation, which stood at 194.07% in April 2021.

 

Conclusion

The Nigerian government needs to intensify its revenue generation efforts and step up measures towards economic diversification to reduce its vulnerability to oil price shocks. The current focus on the development of the agriculture sector is commendable. However, there is the need for an effective monitoring process to track the progress of several agriculture interventions schemes and areas requiring improvement. The government should also adopt business-friendly economic policies to encourage growth in other sectors of the economy such as manufacturing, mining, trading and ICT. This will help broaden the government's revenue base and reduce reliance on oil. Moreover, the government needs to be committed to fiscal discipline to prevent an increase in the country's debt burden and the risk of a credit rating downgrade.


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related News

  1. Nigeria's Deficit Monetisation May Raise Macro-Stability Risks
  2. NNPC Set to Deliver Zero FAAC Remittance in May as Subsidy Payment Bites Harder
  3. The Strange Yield Curve
  4. Planning for 400million: Nigeria's Opportunities and Challenges - 2050
  5. Hospitality Post-COVID-19: Making the Future Count
  6. BOFIA 2020: Impact on the Financial Services Industry
  7. Naira Bonds Sell-Off, US Bonds Rise
  8. A Case for the FGN's Reform to Focus on Household Income Growth
  9. Inflation Rate: The 18.17% Rise of a Monster
  10. Economic Recovery is Gaining Momentum Globally - Comercio March 2021 Report
  11. Inflationary Pressures to Feed Expectations for Further Yield Increases
  12. Headline Inflation Crosses the 18% Threshold
  13. Headline Inflation Increases by 18.17% YoY In March 2021, 0.82% Higher Than February 2021 Rate - NBS
  14. Oil Prices to the Rescue?
  15. NBS Publishes COVID-19 Impact Monitoring Survey Report for February 2021


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related News -Monetary Policy

  1. Personal Statements By The MPC Members At The 135 MPC Meeting of Mar 22-23, 2021
  2. A Decent Rise in PSCE, Increased by 10.6% YoY to N31.25trn in March 2021
  3. Is the CBN's Fiat-led Intervention Working?
  4. A Further Welcome Advance in PSCE in February 2021
  5. Post MPC - March 2021: Status Quo But Tightening in Sight
  6. MPC Maintains Status Quo as Stagflation Remains Unbridled
  7. CBN Communique No. 135 of the MPC Meeting - Mar 22-23, 2021
  8. The Argument for No Change from the MPC
  9. Pre-MPC March 2021: A Hold Decision in View but MPC to Soften Dovish Tone
  10. Ahead of the 2nd MPC Meeting for 2021, We Expect No Changes to Key Parameters
  11. Jan 2021 MPC Meeting: Ten Committee Members, One Chorus
  12. The Evidence is in on Negative Interest Rate Policies
  13. Central Bank of Nigeria and OMO Bills: Tough Love?
  14. Continuing Double-Digit Growth in PSCE in January 2021
  15. Personal Statements by the MPC Members at the 134 MPC Meeting of Jan 25-26, 2021
  16. Higher Interest Rates - Necessary But Not Sufficient to Curb Inflation
  17. Welcome Pick-up in PSCE Growth in December 2020
  18. CBN Deals the House Card as Policy Rates Remain Unchanged

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP