The Argument for No Change from the MPC


Monday, March 22, 2021  / 10:34AM / By FBNQuest Research / Header Image Credit: Africa Report

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


The monetary policy committee (MPC) holds its latest meeting today and tomorrow. In the earlier days of the COVID-19 pandemic rate-setting bodies globally were in easing mode and eager to provide a monetary stimulus. Indeed the MPC cut its policy rate twice in 2020. The most common decision has since been 'hold' although a few in the EM universe such as Turkey have shifted to a tightening stance. A third rate cut would be a surprise this week, given the persistent rise in inflation for 18 successive months. The committee argued in January that easing would increase negative real interest rates. This argument has since been reinforced. The risk from tightening at the time was that it would add to borrowing costs, and thus undermine efforts to restore growth and support job creation. The MPC opted then for a 'hold' decision and is likely to do so again this week.


Since January we have had the pleasant surprise of a return to GDP growth in Q4 2020, albeit a modest 0.1% y/y. Our take is that we cannot ignore the possibility of a negative figure in Q1 '21 (Good Morning Nigeria, 19 February 2021). The authorities, however, are likely to view the pleasant surprise as the beginning of a rebound in output.


As the rebound gathers momentum, the committee argued, the negative output gap closes and inflationary pressures ease. We should say that many of these pressures are supply-side or, to use the MPC's terminology, "legacy structural factors". Poor roads and insecurity in growing areas, for example, are not quickly solved.


Since January we have also had the latest labour market report from the National Bureau of Statistics. The increase in the unemployment rate to 33.3% in Q4 '20  is another reason not to tighten: job creation is enough of a challenge without a rise in borrowing costs. If we take together the unemployment rate and Nigeria's strict definition of the underemployment rate, we come to 49.2% for Q4.


If, as the MPC appeared to feel two months ago, a rebound in output was underway (before the national accounts for Q4 '20), then the labour market report is a reason for another 'hold' decision.


The global economic landscape has become more Nigeria-friendly. The recovery of the Chinese economy has continued, the oil price has firmed thanks largely to Saudi output restraint, the US Congress has approved the USD1.9trn stimulus package of the Biden administration and the rollout of vaccines has been impressive in some advanced economies. We will be curious to see the committee's view on the impact of the improvements on the Nigerian economy.


The MPC tends to comment sensitively, if at all, on the fx regime. There is, of course, a large overlap between committee membership and the most senior ranks of the CBN. That said, we cannot see evidence that the CBN is having second thoughts on the naira exchange rate(s).


Some of our counterparts, particularly those employed by large international banks, argue that the CBN is making its way back to policy orthodoxy. We think otherwise, and recall that the head of monetary policy was contradicted by the governor earlier this month for suggesting that OMO bills would again become tools for liquidity management and nothing more.


If we are searching for more evidence of the CBN's heterodoxy, we need look no further than its burgeoning role in development finance. By January the CBN had already disbursed NGN2trn in its credit response to COVID-19.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News

1.      Pre-MPC March 2021: A Hold Decision in View but MPC to Soften Dovish Tone

2.     Ahead of the 2nd MPC Meeting for 2021, We Expect No Changes to Key Parameters

3.     Jan 2021 MPC Meeting: Ten Committee Members, One Chorus

4.     The Evidence is in on Negative Interest Rate Policies

5.     Central Bank of Nigeria and OMO Bills: Tough Love?

6.     Continuing Double-Digit Growth in PSCE in January 2021

7.     Personal Statements by the MPC Members at the 134 MPC Meeting of Jan 25-26, 2021

8.     Higher Interest Rates - Necessary But Not Sufficient to Curb Inflation

9.     Welcome Pick-up in PSCE Growth in December 2020

10.  CBN Deals the House Card as Policy Rates Remain Unchanged

11.   MPC: Carry on for Another Two Months or More

12.  CBN Communique No. 134 of the MPC Meeting - Jan 25-26, 2021

13.  MPC Holds All Policy Parameters at the End of Its First Meeting in 2021

14.  A Compelling Case for Another Hold from the MPC

15.  Pre-MPC January 2021: MPC to Maintain Policy Rates

16.  Monetary and Interest Rate Policy in 2021: Going for Growth

17.  CBN to Sustain Expansionary Monetary Policy Till Q1, 2021 - Cordros Securities

18.  Ten MPC Members, One Shared Outlook

19.  Further Slowdown in PSCE Growth in November 2020

20. Personal Statements By The MPC Members At The 133 MPC Meeting of Nov 23-24, 2020

21.  CBN Rolls the Dice to Tackle Market Liquidity and Dollar Dearth

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News