How to Stabilize the Naira - Ayo Teriba

Proshare

Tuesday, September 28, 2021 / 09:07 AM / By Dr. Ayo Teriba / Header Image Credit: Ecographics

 

Recent slides in the official exchange rate of the Naira and the dramatic widening of the parallel market premium signaled that the unease in the Nigerian foreign market has intensified, testing our capacity as a nation to stabilize the Naira.

 

This piece simplifies the forces at work and identifies fruitful paths to a stable Naira.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

1.   Crucial Role of Pandemic-Related Trade Shocks

We must remind ourselves that the current exchange rate crisis is triggered by the foreign exchange supply shortfalls in the wake of the pandemic-induced global lockdown in 2020.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Source: 2020 Statistical Bulletin, Central Bank of Nigeria.

 

a.   Nigeria's annual average net goods exports inflow of US$34 billion from 2005 to 2014 had dropped to an annual average inflow of US$5.9 billion from 2015 to 2019, before dipping steeply into steep net outflow of -US$16.4 billion in 2020 (that was a US50 billion shortfall relative to the 2005-2014 average) and it is likely to remain a net outflow in 2021.

b.     Balances on Nigeria's trade in services and incomes have historically been negative.

c.     Remittances is now the only source of net inflow on Nigeria's current account, with annual average inflow of US$21 billion from 2005 to 2020. This was not large enough to offset deficits from goods, services, and income, leaving the current account in a steep deficit of -US$16.98 billion in 2020.

d.     The combined FDI and ODA inflows of about 5.2 billion were offset by FPI outflows of 3.6 billion to leave net capital inflows at a paltry 1.7 billion in 2020.

 

Nigeria's external payments situation is unlikely to change much in 2021 as we have done nothing to reposition to attract the types of the liquidity inflows that are abundantly available in the prevailing global environment like many of our peers are already doing as shown below.

 

2.  The Role of Supply

Overall foreign exchange supply conditions are determined in part by:

  1. Generic developments in external trade and payments conditions that have reduced net-inflows of foreign exchange into Nigeria, and indeed all other countries.
  2. Government's capacity to boost the sizes of net-inflows from targeted components of the current and capital accounts, especially in the face of pandemic-related downswings in global economic conditions that helped some countries blunt the edges of adverse generic shocks.
  3. Confidence or lack of confidence of residents and non-residents in the ability of the government to stabilize supply in the event of adverse shocks could inform their decisions on whether to hoard or sell foreign exchange, especially in the face of crisis.

 

3.  The Role of Demand

Demand conditions are determined by

  1. Transactions' demand to meet routine external trade and financial obligations, could largely be procyclical
  2. Precautionary demand to meet unexpected external trade and payments obligations, would increase in times of uncertainty.
  3. Speculative demand to seize external investment or portfolio optimization opportunities, would explode in times of uncertainty.

 

4.  Exchange Rate as An Indicator

The Naira exchange rate against the US dollar is a mirror that helps us to track how good we look in ensuring adequate levels of foreign reserves to meet readily foreseeable transactions demand for forex required for routine external payments, not-so-foreseeable precautionary demand required to cope with unexpected external shocks, and largely unforeseeable speculative demand required to seize external investment and portfolio optimization opportunities.

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

We looked and felt very good in front of that mirror when our external reserve situation improves steadily to stay well above the US$35 billion, like 2006 to 2014, often affording ourselves some boasting rights on how successful our economic policies had been.

 

Conversely, we looked and felt very bad in front of that mirror when our external reserve situation deteriorates precipitously to drop below US$35 billion like 2015 to 2017 when the Naira fell precipitously from 120/US$ to 360/US$, and 2020 to 2021 when it fell further to 410/US$ in official wholesale market segment, and US$575 in unofficial retail market segment, often pushing us to live in denial, try to obstruct access of buyers and/or retail dealers to foreign exchange market, try to cover the mirror, break the mirror, or even blame market operatives for the woes.

 

Shortfalls in foreign exchange supply, or foreign exchange reserves, relative to demand are the most common fundamental sources of exchange rate instability, although confidence-related demand shocks are known to have triggered exchange rate crisis even in the absence of supply shortfall or aggravate crisis that originally broke out because of supply shortfalls.

 

The exchange rate is a mere indicator of the balance of supply and demand forces in the foreign exchange market. Those who are discussing exchange rate developments without reference to the unfolding realities of demand and supply are chasing the shadows instead of substance.

 

5.  Exchange Rate Premium is Informative

Wherever governments try to cover up supply shortfalls by pegging the official exchange rate at a value that does not equate supply with demand, gaps, spreads, or premiums emerge between rates in official and parallel market segments. These premiums are very informative when the market is out of equilibrium as they largely reflect the size of the supply shortfalls or the distance of pegged exchange rate from market realities. The trend of the premium reveal useful news which no market participant can afford to ignore. Policies should be guided by them, rather than ignore, or suppress that news.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

6.  How we should address the crisis

Increasing foreign exchange supply is the only enduring way to narrow or close premiums. We should learn that it is just as futile to try to curtail demand for forex as it is to try to control the price of forex. Supply of forex is the only variable that we should be trying to boost.

 

The sooner we refocus our efforts on how to substantially boost foreign exchange supply in Nigeria, through balance-sheet-related foreign exchange inflows that are fueled by the unprecedented global liquidity glut, rather than transactions-related foreign exchange inflows that are adversely affected by weakening global commodity prices, the better.

 

Most other oil exporting developing countries have shifted from relying on oil exports for foreign exchange supply towards asset-based securities that is helping them to attract bigger net foreign exchange inflows than oil could ever have brought even in the best of times.

 

Fighting over exchange rate premium distracts us from concentrating on how to raise large sums from global asset-based securities like progressive developing countries are doing.

 


 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

7.  Connecting to Global Wave of Asset-Linked Securitization

Opportunities for issuing asset-based securities that will connect global liquidity into local assets internationally, other countries are seizing heavily on these opportunities, but Nigeria continues to shun such opportunities by focusing on exchange rate and demand-side participants rather than how to boost supply.

 

Global wave of asset-linked securitization increasingly converts dead, idle, and underutilized public corporate, infrastructure, physical, and intangible assets into new sources of immediate fiscal liquidity and future revenue flows that are required to close infrastructure gaps and unlock latent growth potentials, without the burden of interest payments through the budget, as commercial investors in such securities are happy to wait for the profits or rent to be unlocked by the assets, mostly at their own risk, with the comfort that most of such securities have investment grade ratings by foremost agencies.

 

8.  The Way Forward

We should create special purpose vehicles for packaging infrastructure assets for big-ticket interest-free financing through asset-linked non-convertible or convertible bonds. The gains of India and a few other countries who have learnt to attract record levels of foreign capital inflows by issuing asset-based bonds targeted at their diaspora, the breakthroughs of China, Brazil, India, and a few other developing countries in leveraging on local assets to receive record levels of global equity inflows through cross-border mergers and acquisitions and greenfield deals, and the successes of Malaysia, Saudi Arabia, and about six other oil producing countries in issuing interest-free commercial bonds to replace interest paying ones, all show that Nigeria's options for boosting non-oil, non-export liquidity in the prevailing global milieu are endless!

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

 

About the Author

The Author, Dr. Ayo Teriba is the CEO of Economic Associates  and can be reached via email at ayo.teriba@econassociates.com. Click here to go to Author's Page



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

 

Related News - Dr. Ayo Teriba /Economic Associates

1.     VIDEO: Global Economy 2021: 4 Interesting Trends To Watch - Dr Ayo Teriba

2.    Finding a Way Out of Nigeria's High Debt Costs - Ayo Teriba - Proshare, Sept 22, 2021

3.    Insights on VAT Collection and Distribution in Nigeria - Ayo Teriba - Proshare, 20 Sept, 2021

4.    Economic Associate's Conference on Nigeria's Economic Outlook to Hold in 3 States this September - Proshare, 06 Sept, 2021

5.    VIDEOHighlights of the June 2021 Economic Associates One-Day Nigerian Economic Outlook Conference

6.    Nigerian Economist Ayo Teriba Advises FG to Liberalize the Services Sector  June 24, 2021

7.     Dr. Ayo Teriba to Speak on Nigeria and The Trilemma Of Debt, Revenue and Liquidity  July 08, 2020

8.    Nigeria Needs to Generate Liquidity To Ensure Growth and Stability - Dr. Ayo Teriba , April 14, 2020

9.    Liquidity Still The Key Factor in Nigeria's Economic Stability in 2020 - Dr Ayo Teriba , December 17, 2019

10.Awoyemi, Awosika, Teriba, Olukanni speak on Outlook for Nigeria's Economy In 2020 , December 17, 2019

11.  Unlocking Liquidity in Nigeria - Ayo Teriba , October 14, 2019

12. Unlocking Liquidity Will Restore Growth and Stability for Nigeria - Ayo TeribaJuly 19, 2019

13. Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on April 10, 2019

14. Africa Economic Outlook - Ayo Teriba -  May 31, 2019

15. Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on September 27, 2018

16. Economic Associate's Conference on 'Nigeria's Economic Outlook', to hold on June 21, 2018



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - Monetary Policy

1.      CBN Communique No. 138 of the MPC Meeting - Sep 16-17, 2021

2.     September 2021 MPC Meeting: CBN Retains All Policy Parameters

3.     Pre-MPC Note: Will Status Quo Be Maintained?

4.     A Winning Formula for MPC Members

5.     Personal Statements by the MPC Members at the 137 MPC Meeting of July 26-27, 2021

6.     Single-Digit Growth in PSCE in July 2021

7.     Post MPC - July 2021: Reactive in Action... Proactive in Guidance

8.     A Slowdown in Growth in PSCE, Rose by 10.9% in June 2021 to N32.64trn

9.     CBN Stops Sale of FX to BDCs, Holds Policy Parameters Constant

10.  CBN Communique No. 137 of the MPC Meeting - July 26-27, 2021

11.   July 2021 MPC Meeting: CBN Holds All Policy Parameters, Stops Sales of FX to BDCs

12.  The Rationale for No Change in the MPC's Stance

13.  Personal Statement of MPC: If It Ain't Broke...

14.  Personal Statements by the MPC Members at the 136 MPC Meeting of May 24-25, 2021

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related News - Nigeria's Debt/DMO

1.      Nigeria: Sale of Assets as Dangerous Policy Myopia?

2.     The Impact of COVID-19 on Business Enterprises in Nigeria

3.     Nigeria Raises USD4bn through Eurobonds; 30-Year Eurobonds Raised at 8.25% - DMO - Proshare, 22 Sept, 2021

4.     The Debt Management Office (DMO) Nigeria

5.     Debt Profile - Debt Management Office Nigeria

6.     Debt Stock Rises to N35.5tn in June 2021

7.     FGN and Public Debt Stock Still Manageable

8.     DMO finalizes plan to restructure CBN's N10trn overdrafts to a long-term tenured debt - Onyinye Nwachukwu, Businessday, 15 Sept 2021

9.     Nigeria's Fiscal Position, A Lot Like Deja Vu

10.  Nigeria Fiscal Guide 2020

11.   DMO Clarifies China's Loans to Nigeria; Economic Viability and Revenue Issues Left Out

12.  DMO Publishes 2019 Debt Sustainability Analysis Report

13.  DMO Reacts to Media Publication on the Listing of Nigeria, Nine Others as High-Debt Risk Nations

14.  Nigeria on the Debt Precipice: Spent N1.8trn on Debt Servicing in First Five Months of 2021

15.  Q1 2021 Debt Data: Domestic Debt Service on a Plateau

16.  Q1 2021 Total Debt Figure: Moderate Risk of Distress Despite Rising Debt Level

17.  37.67% of Nigeria's Total Public Debt Was External as of Q1 2021 - NBS

18.  Two-thirds of the FGN's External Debt Concessionary

19.  Q1 2021 Total Debt Figure: Moderate Risk of Distress Despite Rising Debt Level

20. Public and FGN Domestic Debt Ratios under Control

21.  Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood at N33.11trn as of March 31, 2021 - DMO

22. Modest Burden of External Debt Service in Q4 2020

23. A Rise in Domestic Debt Service in Q4 2020

24. 38.60% of Nigeria's Total Public Debt Was External in Q4 2020 - NBS

25. Q4 2020 External Debt Data: World Bank Heads the FGN's External Creditor List

26. A Modest Increase in FGN Domestic Debt in Q4 2020

27. Nigeria's Total Public Debt Stood at N32.92trn as of December 31, 2020 - DMO


 

 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News on Budget and Plans

1.      $4bn Eurobond: Implications for the Currency and Fiscal Position

2.     Senate Approves Medium-Term Expenditure Framework

3.     Nigeria Raises USD4bn through Eurobonds; 30-Year Eurobonds Raised at 8.25%

4.     An Aggressive Fiscal Stance in 2021

5.     External Borrowing Plan: Presidency Lists Projects, Beneficiaries

6.     Fitch Assigns Nigeria's Proposed USD Bond 'B' Rating

7.     Nigeria Back at International Capital Market with Eurobond Offer

8.     2021 Appropriation Act: FGN Appoints Transaction Advisers for a Eurobond Issuance

9.     MTNDP 2021-2025: A Hope for Revival or Keeping up With the Joneses?

10.  2022-2024 MTEF and FSP Will Provide Guidance to MDAs

11.   DMO Issues Update on the N2.343trn New Capital Raising in the 2021 Appropriation Act

12.  President Buhari Requests for NASS Resolution for N2.343trn New Capital Raising

13.  2021 Budget: FG Asked to Block Loopholes and Investigate 314 Duplicated Projects

14.  BudgIT Highlights Corruption Loopholes in the Budget Process, Calls for Urgent Budget Reforms

15.  2021 National Budget - KPMG Review and Implementation Notes

16.  Budget Shortfalls and Revenue Underperformance

17.  DMO Provides Clarification on the N2.2trn Debt Service Provision in the 2018 Appropriation Act

18.  Budget and National Strategy: Leverage and Synergy Potentials

19.  Lagos State Budget 2021: Rekindling Hope, Riding Expectations

20. 2021 Budget to Focus on Security, Human Capital Development and Infrastructure - Zainab Ahmed

21.  President Signs the Appropriation Bill, 2021 and Finance Bill, 2020

22. Nigeria's Growing Budget Deficit

23. President Buhari Signs Nigeria's 2021 Appropriation Bill and Finance Bill Into Law

24. President Buhari Signs Budget 2021 into Law

25. 2021 Proposed Budget Review: Galloping Spending, Weakening Revenues

26. Subpar Expenditure, Subpar Revenue Collection

27. Nigeria's 2021 Budget of Economic Recovery and Resilience

28. FGN Proposes Unprecedented Deficit to Drive Economic Recovery

29. Nigeria's 2021 Budget of Economic Recovery and Resilience

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP