Banking Sector Update - Banks May Wobble on MPC's CRR Move


Monday, January 27, 2020 /1o:56 AM /  By CardinalStone Research / Header Image Credit: Brand Spur


In its latest meeting, the Monetary Policy Committee (MPC) announced an increase in cash reserve ratio (CRR) from 22.5% to 27.5%, the first raise since March 2016. Of all the considerations given for the surprise adjustment, the need to combat liquidity-driven inflation was notable. The impact of the CRR increase is likely to be diametrically opposed to that of the loan-to-deposit ratio (LDR) measure already at play, in our view. Specifically, while the LDR measure is configured to induce bank lending, the CRR increase could curtail banks' ability to achieve that objective with more funds likely to be sterilized.


We see the following as broad implications of the policy move:


  1. Banks' effective CRR may increase

Despite the regulatory requirement of 22.5%, effective CRR have ranged between 27.0% and 35.0% in the sector, according to our recent correspondence with coverage names. CBN's data also suggests an average effective CRR of 29.4% for deposit and non-interest banks as at September 2019. Itis unclear if banks' excess CRR would be applied to their credit upon assessment of compliance to the new regulatory CRR of 27.5%. Our base case scenario is that the CBN would enforce the additional 500bps CRR on banks irrespective of their effective positions. This assumption appears to be consistent with historical precedent that saw a 250bps increase in regulatory CRR to 22.5% in March 2016 cascade to a surge in effective CRR to 26.0% in March 2016 (vs. 23.7% previously). In contrast, we note that if banks' excess CRR is applied to their credit in the evaluation of compliance to the new CRR of 27.5%, the MPC decision is likely to have an insignificant impact on our coverage names.


  1. We expect broad based application of the the measure

In our view, the 500 bps additional CRR is likely to be applied on already existing deposits, not on new funds alone. Although some banks have said they await clarity from the CBN in this regard, historical precedent suggests a retrospective application is on the cards. This could imply that an additional N817.5 billion of funds could be sterilized in the banking sector causing the effective CRR to increase to 34.4%.


  1. Banks' liquidity could tighten, leading to a scramble for funds and a negative consequence for funding cost.

Higher CRR and LDR requirements suggest that banks could potentially have limited funds for other play, including investments in treasuries. In our view, this could lead to a scramble for funds especially in consideration of a likely slowdown in OMO maturities in coming quarters, and possibly slowdown the previously expected moderation in funding costs for FY'20.


  1. We see downside risks to banks' earnings, but mildimplications for valuations.

Theoretically, an increase in CRR invariably results in higher lending rates, given the resulting liquidity constraint for lending purposes. However, we do not see the MPC's decision as a signal that the CBN is letting up on its LDR demands to C January 27, 2020 banks. Hence, taking into cognizance the likely constraint on investments in government securities, we are slightly worried about prospects for earnings growth across our coverage. Specifically, while we see slightly higher than previously expected cost of funds for FY'20, we retain our view that asset yields could remain depressed in the current year-although fixed income yields could trend higher, banks abiltiy to deploy funds to fixed income securities may be constrained by the CBN's measures. Notwithstanding, we expect the impact to be less severe for UBA and ETI given their hugely diversified regional operations. We also expect banks with huge FCY deposits to be less impacted than their peers given the exclusion of FCY deposits from CRR assessment.


All in, we see the likelihood of a 4.3% reduction on average for our coverage earnings projections. However, we expect the impact to be minimal on our target prices-which could potentially fall by 0.8% on average-and hence, retain our recommendations.


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News -Monetary Policy

  1. CBN MPC Calls On FG To Improve Security, Address Infrastructure Deficit
  2. CBN Communique No. 128 of the MPC Meeting - Jan 23-24, 2020
  3. Understanding Emefiele's Silver Bullet - Sonnie Ayere
  4. CBN MPC Retains MPR and Liquidity Ratio; Raises CRR to 27.5% In First Meeting of 2020
  5. MPC Preview: Dovish Stance but Hawkish Actions
  6. Ignoring LIBOR Cessation May Raise US Leveraged Loan Credit Risk
  7. The MPC Members In One Accord; Verdict Of The Committee Was Unanimous
  8. Personal Statements By The MPC Members At The 127 MPC Meeting Of Nov 25-26, 2019
  9. CBN's Regulatory Measures To Improve Lending To The Real Sector: Impact And Challenges
  10. GDP Growth: How Far Can Monetary Policy Go?
  11. Rates Continue to Decline as Banks Struggle to Meet CBN's 65% Minimum LDR


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News On Banking Sector

1.       Banking Sector Update - CBN Wields Regulatory Stick Again

2.      Bank Equity Returns Do Not Look So Good in 2019

3.      Nigerian Banks: A Season of Mixed Performance; Reviewing The Growth Numbers

4.      ETI: Walking A Tight Rope; Earnings Down As Continental Headwinds Persist

5.      UBA 9 Months 2019 Result; Strong Top Line Earnings, Stable Outlook

6.      FBNH's Sober Year; Soft Top Line Earnings, Modest Bottom Line Growth 9M 2019

7.       Zenith Bank 9 months 2019 Result; Strong Profit Outlook from Ebusiness, Modest Top Line Earnings

8.      Access Bank 9Months 2019 Result; Strong Earnings, But OPEX Rises 47.7%

9.      GT Bank 9M 2019; Good Numbers, But A Howler In Loan Asset Growth

10.   Unity Bank Plc Q3 2019 Results: Pulling Out of A Ditch Slowly

11.    Banks' H1 2019 Numbers: Top Line Growth, Bottom Line Uncertainty

12.   Banking Sector Update - CBN Makes Statement Move On Intention To Drive Lending

13.   12 Banks To Pay N499b CBN Fine For Loan Policy Breach

14.   Nigerian Banks Tried, But 'Not All' Made New Loans Threshold

15.   CBN Reviews LDR Target Upwards To 65%; DMBs Required To Attain LDR of 65% By Dec 31, 2019

16.   CBN's New Minimum LDR Requirement May Worsen NPLs

17.   CBN Mandates DMBs To Maintain Loan To Deposit Ratio Of 60% Effective Sept 30, 2019

18.   Nigerian Banks' Performance - H1 2018

19.   FBNHoldings Plc Q1' 2017 Performance Assessment Report Updated

20.  Analysing the Performance of FBN Holdings Plc - A Comprehensive Report

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News