SEC Charges Two Brokers With Defrauding Customers


Tuesday, September 11, 2018       06.41AM  / SEC (US)


The US Securities and Exchange Commission charged two brokers for recommending excessive levels of trading that were costly for retail customers but lucrative for the brokers. 


In separate complaints filed in federal court in Manhattan on Friday, the SEC alleges that Florida resident Emil Botvinnik and New York resident Jovannie Aquino recommended frequent, short-term trades that generated large commissions for the brokers but were almost guaranteed to lose money for their customers. According to the SEC’s complaints, Botvinnik’s and Aquino’s customers – a number of whom were at or near retirement age – lost approximately $3.6 million as a result of the trades while the brokers pocketed approximately $4.6 million in commissions.  


“We are diligently pursuing deceitful brokers who prey on their customers,” said Antonia Chion, Associate Director in the SEC’s Division of Enforcement and Chair of the Enforcement Division’s Broker-Dealer Task Force. “Brokers need to ensure that the level of trading they recommend is suitable for their customers, and investors should be on the lookout for frequent trading in their accounts.”  


The complaints also allege that both brokers engaged in unauthorized trading and concealed material information from their customers about the transaction costs associated with their recommendations, which were likely to outstrip any potential monetary gains in the accounts.  


The case follows similar charges of excessive trading by brokers brought in JanuarySeptember, and December 2017. The SEC previously issued an Investor Alert warning about excessive trading and churning that can occur in brokerage accounts.


The SEC’s complaints charge Botvinnik and Aquino with violations of antifraud provisions of the federal securities laws.


The SEC’s investigation was conducted by Yael Berger, Jacqueline O’Reilly, Pamela Nolan, and Gregory Bockin, with assistance from Michael Fiorbello. The litigation will be led by Mr. Bockin, Ms. Berger, Ms. O’Reilly, and Samantha Williams. The case is being supervised by Ms. Chion, Stacy Bogert, and Cheryl Crumpton. 


Related Materials

·         SEC Complaint - Botvinnik

·         SEC Complaint - Aquino



 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Related News

1.            Whistleblower Accuses AlphaBeta Of Tax Evasion, Money Laundering

2.           MTN Seeks Judicial Intervention, Sues The Attorney General and Central Bank Over $10.1b Demand

3.           Banks, MTN Engage CBN Over $8.1b Fine; Factually Incorrect Premises Highlighted

4.           International Fraud On The Increase – UK Report

5.           Nine FCMB Staff Declared Wanted Over Alleged Multi-Million Naira Customer Deposit Fraud

6.           Who Owns Legacy Shares After $864m Write Off At Ecobank; Post Securities Fraud

7.           Fraudsters May Pose As Brokers Selling Pending IPO or pre-IPO Shares Of Well-known Firms

8.          10 Red Flags That An Unregistered Offering May Be A Scam

9.           Ponzi Scheme - “Red Flags” And How To Spot One

10.       FHC Grants Judgment In Favour Of Olisa Agbakoba In Margin Loan Case; Orders First Bank To Pay Damage

11.        Crime and Insecurity: Most Important Problem In Zamfara State - NBS 2017 Report

12.       Anti-Corruption Compliance In High Risk Markets

13.       FHC Declares Attempted Takeover of EkoCORP A Criminal Act, Orders AGM

14.       Minister Kemi Adeosun’s NYSC Certificate

15.    The $680m July 6, 2018 Judgment by The London Court of International Arbitration (LCIA) London 
Related News