How Imminent Is A Naira Devaluation?

Proshare - Facebook Proshare - Twitter Proshare - Linked In Proshare - WhatsApp

Friday, September 27, 2019 / 09:43PM / CardinalStone Research// Header Image Credit:  AboveWhispers


Emerging risks provoke another devaluation enquiry

The naira has witnessed relative stability, moving within a narrow band of N359-N370/$ since mid-2017. This period of naira stability was preceded by the introduction of the Investors and Exporters FX window in April 2017 and supported by a notable recovery in global oil price (2017 Brent price: +16.0% YoY to $54.77/barrel), following the collapse of the latter in 2016. 

In view of the decline in reserves over the last two months ($2.2 billion) and the emergence of pertinent risks, such as the $9.6 billion judgement granted against Nigeria in favour of Process and Industrial Developments Limited (P&ID), we revisit the case for an adjustment to the current currency regime in this report. Specifically, we discuss the likelihood of devaluation in the near term, partly by juxtaposing current realities with conditions prevalent in 2016, when the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) was compelled to devalue the currency after months of applying ad hoc administrative measures.


Will the CBN need to devalue soon?

CBN's ability to sustain its currency defense is a function of the strength of the nation's FX reserves. The reservelevel, in turn, is influenced by factors such as crude oil revenue, foreign capital flows, current account flows, changes in dollar-denominated obligations, and other foreign currency denominated arrangements. Nigeria's external reservesis currently at c. $42.3 billion, which, by our estimate, translates to a worst-case scenario position of c. $15.0 billion (equivalent to 3.5x import cover) after adjusting for the riskier portions of the reserve, as well as the FGN and federation portions. For clarity, our worst-case (adjusted)scenario level of foreign reserves strips out the portion of the reserves subject to claims by third parties and, as such, already accounts for possible impact of capital flights-a typical trigger for currency repricing. However, we note that an increased supply of the local currency, precipitated by capital flights, could, nonetheless lead to heighten pressure on naira and force a stronger draw-down on the relatively "less-vulnerable" portion of reserves to defend the currency.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


While the CBN would prefer a much higher adjusted reserve level, we highlight that our estimate for the current period, at $15 billion, is c. $2.8 billion higher than the corresponding adjusted level in 2016, when the CBN succumbed to currency pressures. This exercise suggests   that the CBN is likely to face increasing pressure to devalue the currency in the coming months if the current rate of reserve depletion ($1.1 billion per month) persists. 

However, our base case, and more likely scenario, is that the CBN will focus on what is currently available to defend the currency ($34.9 billion) and bet that its efforts to keep Nigeria's carry trade opportunity attractive will motivate foreign portfolio investors to roll-over their positions. This position is largely consistent with the CBN Governor's recent declaration that the Monetary Policy Committee would only reduce rates when inflation hits single digit- a development that is largely doubtful in the near term in view of imminent increases in electricity tariff and minimum wage, as well as the ongoing stiffer border enforcements. On this wise, the risks of significant capital flight and devaluation is likely to be muted in the near term. 

In addition to the above exercise, we look at relative changes to medium-to-long term determinants of our adjusted reserves, including crude oil revenue and current & financial accounts movements. Leading up to the last devaluation in 2016, crude oil revenue was on the downtrend as oil price plummeted below $28/barrel levels (and averaged $40.9 in H1'16). Similarly, oil production plunged to a decade low of 1.5mbpd. We hold the view that the decline in oil price and production in 2016 occasioned foreign capital flight, which was heightened by CBN's slow policy adjustments and recourse to dollar rationing. By contrast, crude oil prices have so far averaged $64.8/barrel in 2019, while mean oil production (c.2.0mbpd) is c. 25.0% higher than the levels seen in the build up to 2016 devaluation. 

That said, Nigeria's services-induced surge in current account deficit to $5.6 billion in H1'19 (H1'16: $576 million) has done the NGN no good from a medium-to-long term fundamental standpoint. This case becomes more worrying when viewed against the backdrop of the negative balance in financial accounts in H1'19. To our minds, weaknesses in Balance of Payments (BoP) could pressure the CBN to "bite the bullet" on the currency management front at some point in the future. However, with CBN's portion of reserves still relatively comfortable at c.$34.9 billion (vs. $17.3 billion in 2016), and amid its resolute inclination to hold the peg, it is more likely to consider this "future" a more distant one.


$9.6 billion judgment debt could lead to a material repricing of naira yields

The recent judgement debt of $9.6 billion awarded to P&ID, however, swiftly takes the FGN from a position of comfort to one of unease. The judgement debt,if fully enforced, could lead to a decline in CBN's portion of reserves to $25.3 billion (46.0% higher than the 2016 levels). Assuming this worst-case scenario, the 'adjusted reserve’'level, however, could plummetto $6.5 billion (50% lower than the devaluation levelin 2016). This could potentially trigger foreign capital flight and intensify levels of CBN intervention, hence, deteriorating the foreign reserves position and leading to an upward repricing of naira. In a more likely scenario of an out of courtsettlementto the speculative range of $1-3 billion. We expect the CBN to withstand the negative shock and avoid a devaluation as the reserves level remains above that of 2016, and crude oil revenue remain supportive.


How much longer can the CBN defend the currency?

In view of Nigeria's weak current account position, and the sustainability implications of the currency defense, we believe the CBN will have to weigh the monetary and opportunity costs of defending the currency at some point. We see the main costs of defending the currency as the following; the cost of issuing CBN treasuries at attractive yields, the direct cost of interventions in secondary markets, and the opportunity cost of defending the currency. To defend the currency following the devaluation in mid2016, the CBN increased its issuances of OMO bills from N4.2 trillion in 2016 to N7.7trillion in 2017 and N17.0 trillion in 2018. Between 2017-2019, the CBN issued N35.8 trillion at an average stop rate of 15.1%, which translates to an associated interest expense of c. N5.4 trillion in the period. Our interest expense estimate is corroborated by total interest expense of N4.2 trillion reported in CBN's financial statements of 2017 and 2018 combined (2017: N1.3 trillion; 2018: N2.9 trillion). 

In addition, the CBN also raised the frequency of OMO auctions and its issuance of long-dated securities (300 days and above),thus directly competing with FGN bond issuances and raising the cost of debt of the FGN. Clearly, there is significant cost involved in defending the currency and the costs can manifest in monetary and opportunity cost terms. For context, the interest expense incurred by the CBN in 2018 alone is over 6x the average interest expense recorded in the 4 years leading to 2017. CBN’s 2018 interest expense is also c.75.0% of Federal Government's actual retained revenue and 1.6x the amount spent on capital expenditure in the same year. 

Against the backdrop of weakGDP growth and poor FGN revenue mobilization, the CBN may begin to ponder the opportunity cost of its currency defense on long term growth objectives of the country and the sustainability of these interventions. Evidently, in order to avoid reserve depletion, the CBN is likely to incentivize foreign portfolio managers to roll over existing investments with higher rates at the detriment of the real sector. Furthermore, interest rates are likely to increase even further in coming years, when developed economies reach an inflection point in their economic cycles and begin to experience robust growth, leading to a normalization of interest rates. 

Lastly, the sustenance of this regime will not only leave the foreign reserves more vulnerable to foreign capital flight, but also imply that a devaluation at a later date would be of a higher magnitude given consensus expectations of double-digit inflation in the next two years. Thus, while the CBN is not under immense pressure to devalue in the next 6 months given the current level of its foreign reserves, the risks in favour of naira repricing are now materially higher. The recent constitution of a pro-market economic advisory council by President Buhari may also leave the devaluation discourse on the table in the near-to-medium term.


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News on P and ID

  1. P and ID Directors Plead Guilty To Economic Sabotage - Sep 19, 2019
  2. P and ID vs. Nigeria: A Review by Reuben Abati - Aug 19, 2019
  3. UK Court Rules In Favour of Pand ID To Seize $9bn FGN Assets, Nigeria To Appeal Decision - Aug 16, 2019


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Reports/Articles On FX and Forex Utilisation

  1. FX Food Restrictions: CBI Calls on CBN To Explore Broad Stakeholder Engagement - Sep 25, 2019
  2. FX Restriction On Food Import May Raise Inflation Rate In Q4 2019 - Sep 24, 2019
  3. FX Unification in Nigeria: Simple Thoughts, Tougher Mission - Sep 23, 2019
  4. Stabilization Mechanism: Sticking Half Way through the Line - Aug 24, 2018
  5. Remittances: A Smoothening Agent - May 17, 2018
  6. The Nigeria and China Currency Swap: How Much Room? - May 04, 2018
  7. The Street's Response to the CBN - The Tale of Contradictions - Mar 01, 2017
  8. The Nigerian Forex Situation - Aug 04, 2016
  9. What Banks Used 36.82% of FX allotted for between Jan 2013 to May 2015 - Jan 18, 2016
  10. Manufacturing Sector spent $7.47b (8.61%) of FX between Jan 2013 - May 2015 - Jan 18, 2016
  11. Forex: $1.42m was spent on health related service btw Jan 2013 to May 2015 - Jan 18, 2016
  12. Top 10 Sub-Sectors with Highest FX Utilisation between Jan 2014 and May 2015 - Jan 18, 2016
  13. How Much FX was spent on Telecoms/Technology Related Items (2013 - H1 2015) - Jan 17, 2016
  14. FX Utilisation in Nigeria - Jan 2013 to May 2015: Exclusive Details - Jan 12, 2016

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related News On FX Restrictions On 41 Items

  1. Emefiele Lists Gains of FX Restriction on 41 Items; Outlines Projections for 2018 - Nov 12, 2017
  2. CBN Orders BDCs to Honour Letter of Credit Established Prior to Jun 23rd for 41 Items Ban for FOREX - Oct 23, 2015
  3.  CBN’s 41 'Not Valid for FOREX' Items & Their Sectoral Impacts - Jul 22, 2015
  4.  CBN Limits BDCs cash Purchase to $5,000; Stop Wire Transfer of Funds - Jul 02, 2015
  5. CBN Warns Authorized Dealers Against Funding Items Classified as "Not Valid for Forex" - Jul 01, 2015
  6. CBN Includes Furnitures in Imported Goods and Services Classified as Invalid for Nigerian Forex Market - Jun 24, 2015 


Related News On IEFX Window

  1. Large FX Inflow At IEFX Window Through FPIs In The Fixed Income Market - Mar 06, 2019
  2. The IFEX Window Now a Major Indicator of Value? - Sep 07, 2017
  3. Foreign Investors Boost Foreign Exchange Supply - Sep 06, 2017
  4. Further Liberalization of the Inter-Bank Foreign Exchange (FX) Market -Jun 06, 2017
  5. The New 'Investors and Exporters Window' Framework - Another Step to Improving Liquidity - Apr 24, 2017
  6. CBN Announces the Establishment of Investors' & Exporters' FX Window - Apr 21, 2017


Related News On CBN's Managed Float Exchange Rate System

  1. The Nigerian OTC FX Futures Market…A Panacea for the FX Needs of Corporates in Nigeria - Jun 20, 2016
  2. The Floating Exchange Rate and You - FDC - Jun 21, 2016
  3. The Nigerian Spot FX Two-Way Quote Market Goes Live Post Revised CBN Guidelines Release - Jun 20, 2016
  4. Nigeria's new FX policy - Implication & Impact @Friday - Jun 18, 2016
  5. BREAKING: Window for FXPMD has been Thrown Open to every Deposit Money Bank - Jun 18, 2016
  6. New FX Policy: The CBN Segregates Banks… Who’s in, Who’s out? - Jun 18, 2016
  7. Wisdom Nuggets – Rescuing and Defending the Naira - Jun 17, 2016
  8. Impact of a Unified Exchange Rate and Assessment of Playing Field - Jun 17, 2016
  9. Flexible Exchange Rate: The Bitter Pill - Jun 17, 2016
  10. Guidelines for Primary Dealership in Foreign Exchange Products - Jun 16, 2016
  11. How the CBN Naira-Settled OTC FX Futures Market Will Work - Jun 16, 2016
  12. Exchange-rate flexibility beyond expectation - Jun 16, 2016
  13. The new fully Floated FX Market - In a Nutshell - Jun 16, 2016
  14. Implications for Markets as the CBN finally floats the Naira - Jun 16, 2016
  15. The Nigerian Managed Float Exchange Rate System - Jun 15, 2016
  16. Revised Guidelines for the Operation of the Nigerian Inter-Bank Foreign Exchange Market - Jun 15, 2016
  17. At last Nigeria to adopt flexible exchange rate - May 25, 2016


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News FX Restrictions on Food Imports

  1. Regulatory Conversations 4.0: Forex Restrictions on Food Imports and Implications For The Economy - Sep 13, 2019
  2. FX Restrictions on Food Imports: Experts, Economists Share Their Perspective - Aug 27, 2019
  3. CBN To Expand List Of FX Restrictions On Imported Items -Aug 20, 2019
  4. Letter To Financial Times Editor: Muhammadu Buhari Sparks Dismay Over Policy Shift On Food Imports - Aug 19, 2019
  5. 10 Reasons President Buhari Should Reconsider His Directive To Stop Allocating FX For Food Imports - Aug 15, 2019
  6. President Buhari Directs CBN To Stop Providing Forex For Food Importation To Nigeria - Aug 14, 2019


Related News FX Restrictions on Textile Materials

  1. Import Substitution - CBN Bans FX Sale To Textile Importers - Mar 06, 2019
  2. CBN Places Access to FX for All Forms of Textile Materials on the FX Restriction List - Mar 05, 2019


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


  1. Who Manages the Forex Market? - Mar 04, 2019
  2. Nigeria's Central Bank Adds Fertilizer To Its List of Imports Items Classified as Not Valid For FX - Dec 11, 2018
  3. CBN Introduces Special Intervention Of FOREX Cash Sales To BDC Operators Effective Dec 06, 2018 - Nov 30, 2018
  4. Naira Succumbing To Speculative Pressures - N370 To A Dollar - Nov 30, 2018
  5. Cessation Procedure For the Nigerian Foreign Exchange Fixing (NiFEX) - Apr 27, 2018
  6. Floating Exchange Rate Can Cause Big Trouble - Nov 09, 2017
  7. Repatriation of Oil and Non-Oil Export Proceeds - Oct 30, 2017
  8. Agric, Airline, Oil and Raw Material Sectors Get $285.7m Forex Funding - Oct 27, 2017
  9. Nigeria's Foreign Exchange Dilemma - Sep 07, 2017
  10. Foreign Investors Boost Foreign Exchange Supply - Sep 06, 2017
  11. Unutilized FX Returned to the CBN for the SMIS Wholesale and Retail Interventions - Jul 05, 2017
  12. Further Liberalization of the Inter-Bank Foreign Exchange (FX) Market - Jun 06, 2017
  13. New Code of Conduct to Clean up Foreign Exchange Market's Dirty Reputation is Released - May 26, 2017
  14. CBN Lists 36 Items Valid For FX in the Nigerian Foreign Exchange Markets - May 18, 2017
  15. CBN Announces the Establishment of Investors' & Exporters' FX Window - Apr 21, 2017
  16. Foreign Exchange Payment for Small-scale Importation - Apr 21, 2017
  17. CBN's New FX Policy Shows A Change Of Heart? - Feb'17 Economic Update - Mar 09, 2017
  18. Nigeria reacts positively to a forex crisis of confidence and liquidity - Feb 27, 2017
  19. FT - Lenders Plan Not To Renew Deals with CBN - Dec 15, 2016
  20. Externalisation of Differentials on OTC FX Futures Contracts for Foreign Portfolio Investors - Jun 24, 2016
  21. Nigeria Banks Absorb Effective Devaluation - Jun 24, 2016
  22. Managing Exchange Rate, Interest Rate, Capital Flows and Reserves - May 13, 2016
  23. School Fees and Medicals Remain Eligible for FOREX Allocation - Feb 22, 2016
  24. How crazy can the Nigerian FX market go - Ecobank provides an indication - Feb 20, 2016


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Related News