Enterpreneurship | |
Enterpreneurship | |
2011 VIEWS | |
![]() | |
PROSHARE | |
PROSHARE |
Wednesday, January 15, 2020 / 08:47AM
/ By Tope Fasua / Header
Image Credit: Newco Shift
Ali Mufuruki advised that
African countries not confuse hype with reality, and hope, with achievement.
That was when he spoke at the TEDxEuston event in 2014. He also described
a Tanzanian story where a certain explorer named John Williamson happened on
some locals playing a board game with diamonds, oblivious of the worth of the
precious stones. Williamson bought the entire land around the area for cheap,
built a modern house for the chief, gave out some trinkets and got the colonial
government to ban any local from ever touching such stones even if they found
it in the dirt. He became one of the world's richest men on the back of the
mines he founded. It may sound like some fable or urban legend, but similar
scenarios played out in the colonial days, as African people were taken for
everything we had. Ali was a Tanzanian billionaire himself. He died on the 9th
of December, 2019 in South Africa after an illness.
It's a good time to bring up
this story as I continue to urge for Black African countries - especially
Nigeria - to build capacity, build productivity, and take the long and
sustainable route to development rather than the microwave approach that often
attracts us.
What the locals who didn't know
the value of the stones they played with needed, was not debt or 'foreign
investment', or privatization or any of the esoteric solutions we chase today,
but knowledge, and an ability to use and leverage upon the knowledge they
acquire. I believe black African countries have not yet found the route to
sustainable development.
My concern today is about the
entrepreneurship hype. I recall, like 13 years ago, I was invited to a seminar
by my Master's Degree Alma Mater - London Metropolitan University. One
of the co-invitees headed the Entrepreneurship Centre of one famous Nigerian
university. In promoting his wares, he reminded starry-eyed students and
ex-students that a certain Nigerian businessman had diversified from providing
cleaning services to being the largest supplier of armored cars. He made other
such egregious claims and promote entrepreneurship as a means of merely
acquiring money, that I writhed in my chair. Since then the entrepreneurship
rhetoric has increasingly gained currency in Nigeria. We have even seen a
number of major frauds who had claimed they were entrepreneurs. Anyone
with inexplicable sources of income can hide under the moniker of 'entrepreneur' and get away with it - after all that is the realm in which one
could make untold fortune. Some genuine entrepreneurs have also emerged but I
believe the general approach masks some serious issues which we must of
necessity deal with.
A recent report by The
Economist magazine listed Nigeria as the country with the highest
entrepreneurial activity on earth. Following Nigeria closely are: Zambia,
Senegal, Namibia, Ecuador, Uganda, Cameroon, Botswana, Burkina-Faso, and
Angola. The magazine researched the percentage of our population aged between
18 and 64, who were owner-managers of new business between 2013 and 2018.
Nigeria and Zambia had 39.9% of such people in entrepreneurship. Senegal had
38.6%, while Namibia, Ecuador, Uganda, Cameroon, Botswana, Burkina-Faso and
Angola had 33.3%, 32.7%, 30.4%, 30.1%, 29%, 28.3% and 28.2% respectively.
Perhaps it is a good time to
congratulate ourselves for a job well done for ensuring that the
entrepreneurship drive took hold in Nigeria. But one of the obvious issues with
the list is that almost all of them are from Africa (apart from Ecuador, which
is not a shining economic example from South America).
Unemployment rates have not
reduced in Nigeria. Neither has standards of living improved. I
have picked up research articles in an ongoing project, that concluded that this
entrepreneurship drive is common to nations where the government is ineffective
or absent and the economy has gone through, or is still going through dire
straits. I have also come across the thoughts of people like Ory
Okolloh Mwangi, who spoke about the 'fetishization' of entrepreneurship,
especially in black African nations. Are we being channeled in the wrong
direction? Are we thinking for ourselves at all? Or this is another of those
policy directions we will come to regret in future, while the people who
hijacked our thoughts will issue subtle apologies, as they have when we were
cajoled into mass privatization, liberalization, structural adjustments, high
interest rates, inflation-targeting and the rest.
Meanwhile in another report by the CEO World Magazine, the USA was listed as the best country for entrepreneurship, or the most entrepreneurial country on earth. This time, the indices used include innovation, competitiveness, labour skills and infrastructure. The USA is followed by the United Kingdom, Israel, Poland, Malaysia, UAE, Sweden, India, Germany, Spain, France, Australia, and Estonia, in that order. In this other report, Nigeria was 58th. South Africa is the top country in Africa, at the 51st position, followed directly by Kenya at 52nd. Before we jubilate over The Economist's report, which measures how many people are desperately struggling on their own, sometimes with capital that is so insignificant as to make impact on anyone, themselves inclusive, we need to consider what these two reports measure.
Nigeria is an interesting
specimen, if we consider the fact that with a population of close to 200
million, the demographic of those between 18-64 is indeed large and could be
estimated at probably between 100million and 120million. 40% of that would be
40 and 48million. SMEDAN (Small and Medium Scale Enterprises Development Agency
of Nigeria) has it that we have about 40million of such companies, 99.5% of
which are micro and small.
With the Nigerian government
initiative in passing the Finance Bill (a commendable act), all of these
companies will not be paying a dime in company income taxes, or VAT. With
40million able bodied men and women in entrepreneurship the question is; who
are they selling to? Perhaps those boys in traffic who shove wares in the faces
of commuters, may have also been considered as entrepreneurs, or small business
owners.
There is a negative correlation
between effective governance and this entrepreneurship drive. Like Ory
Okolloh said in 2015, we cannot entrepreneur our ways out of bad or absent
governance (bad schools or none at all, children on the streets in harsh
weather as we have seen in parts of northern Nigeria lately, hopeless health
centres, bad roads and collapsed infrastructure, or wrong-headed public
policies which add more trouble to the society than solve problems). I strongly
believe in that.
We are giving up on the
possibility of achieving good governance in Nigeria especially, as we have
yielded space - out of nothing else but cowardice - to tribal warlords,
out-and-out criminals, motor-park touts, 419 kingpins, to occupy government
positions at all levels - executive, legislature and even the judiciary. The
decay continues. An article in the same Economist magazine, published in
October 2019, and tilted 'Uberising Luck: Africa is full of Schemes to Help
Entrepreneurs - They are hit and miss', took a more critical view at the
outcomes of the many schemes pushing everyone especially in black Africa into
entrepreneurship. One interesting quote from the magazine goes:
"Decent jobs are so scarce
in Africa that... many people create their own. Surveys by the Global
Entrepreneurship Monitor find that one in three working-age adults in
sub-Saharan Africa either runs a new business or is trying to start one,
compared with one in six Americans and one in 20 Germans. In Tanzania informal
firms created four-fifths of new non-farm jobs between 2002 and 2012. Most such
enterprises are also tiny".
I pray for a day that our
youths and adults will go willingly into entrepreneurship because they want to
not because they are pushed by circumstance, or conned into it by governments
desperate to avoid responsibility for a growing population. As we have seen
above, entrepreneurship works in the USA. UK, Germany and so on, because the
conditions are right, the infrastructure is there and those going into
entrepreneurship are adding real value to and making impact on the world in
terms of the sophistication of their end products, not just living from hand to
mouth. Many of those we call entrepreneurs in Nigeria are only one sickness,
one misfortune or one downturn or bad business decision away from poverty.
Their entire venture is not robust enough to actually provide for their needs.
Many are in it just to get active - just to wake up and do something. Nigeria
is wasting such people's lives.
They are better off in public
service, helping society at large, not chasing money around. And I will explain
in a minute.
Before I do, I want to point
out that many of those businesses are not scalable. They never lift off the
ground. They never get beyond me, myself, and I, so they do not create
employment for anyone else apart from this pseudo-employment for the 'solopreneur'.
The challenges of technology
into the future means that there will be more solopreneurs anyway. We are
looking at a future where everyone will stand on their own, supported by
technology. But entrepreneurs from places like Nigeria will hardly match those
from these developed countries who target bigger things. A few of us will
succeed actually, but the numbers will be infinitesimal. Those who don't - in
their many millions - will fall back to the dust in ignominious manner, in a
country where no one gets your back.
The entrepreneurship phenomenon
in Nigeria is explained by underlying theory, I must say.
One theory of entrepreneurship
holds that people go into entrepreneurship sometimes to just prove that they
could be useful, or they could achieve. This is the Achievement Motivation
Theory. Another theory says a traumatized people will usually go into
entrepreneurship en masse e.g. after a war, or a genocide, or after their
former status may have been forcefully removed. This is the Removal of
Status Theory. This is what happened to the Jews, and the Igbos of
Nigeria. We should however be concerned about entrepreneurship that can have
global impact, not such as looks inward and tries to make a point at home.
Related Link: Entrepreneurship Theories: 80+ Theories about Entrepreneurship
Summarized
Back to the Public Sector. We
haven't really built public sector opportunities in Nigeria. The jobs are
there. Look at Social Work? We have almost nothing in that area. Most of those
in public service in developed countries, work in this area. We see mentally
challenged people raising their children on the streets here and nothing
happens. Look at the children in the cold in their millions in the north of
Nigeria today, or the millions of Almajirai (an issue which the wicked elites
have decided to perpetuate while chasing power), these are opportunities to
engage people who have been laid off their jobs rather than tell them to 'go
and start something', sometimes in very rude and arrogant manners.
As I have always said, the
foundation for good, sustainable, value-adding entrepreneurship, is simply not
here. That foundation is in the provision of public good - basic education,
security, environmental services, social services for the vulnerable, basic
health service etc. These provides a sane society upon which good
entrepreneurship will thrive. Entrepreneurship does not thrive in sustained
chaos, except the merchandising of arms, drugs, alcohol, sex, and of course,
corruption. Does that remind us of somewhere?
As I have researched before,
there is also a negative correlation between the percentage of the
workforce who work in public service in a country, and the general
socioeconomic development of such a country, on one hand, and naturally, those
who end up as 'entrepreneurs' on the other. The USA has 17% of her workforce,
working in public service. The UK, 21%. The largest single employers in those
countries are The Department of Defense (3.7million people), and the National
Health Insurance Service (1.7million people), respectively.
The Scandinavian nations are an 'embarrassment' in this regard as roughly 35% of the workforce are retained in
the public service. We know that in Singapore the smartest people are retained
in public service. These numbers are necessary to ensure an orderly society and
get ready for tourists and investors from abroad. Note that most of the
work of civil servants are out there with the people - inspecting, regulating,
cross-checking, delivering direct and indirect service, enforcing, securing - not in secretariats, pushing files and demanding kickbacks.
Here we want our best to do
entrepreneurship and the dullest to run the nation, making policies which
naturally kill the few businesses that have prospects, or ensuring that
mediocrity reigns through corruption and other distortions that have grounded
us as a nation today.
We must rethink and reenact the
public policies running this country.
About
the Author
Tope
Kolade Fasua is a Nigerian businessman, economist and writer. He is the founder
and CEO of Global Analytics Consulting Limited, an international consulting
firm with its headquarters in Abuja, Nigeria. He was the 2019 presidential candidate
of the Abundant Nigeria Renewal Party (ANRP), which he founded. He can be
contacted via e-mail at ceo@global-analytics.co.uk
Recent
Articles by The Author
1.
DSTV, Netflix and the Value of Time; The Real Competition for Our
Mindshare - Tope Fasua - Dec 02, 2019
2.
Thoughts On
Nigeria's Rice Bubble - Fasua - Oct 25,
2019
3.
As for
South Africa, So For Jigawa: Understanding The Missing Point - Fasua - Sept
20, 2019
4.
Why Nigerians
Will Never Leave South Africa - Fasua - Sept 18, 2019
5.
I Ran To
Learn - Tope Fasua - Mar 01, 2019
6.
Fears For The
Nigerian Economy In The Years Ahead - Fasua
7.
Forget It;
Nigeria Is Not Ready for
Agriculture
8.
Nigeria's
Infrastructure Racket - Frauds, Corruption and Shallowness
9.
To Rescue
Nigeria: We Must Go into A War
Mode
10. Shaking
Tables - Poverty Coding and Feminism
On Steroids
11. How To
Un-Break The Nigerian Society And Economy
12. The Illogical
World of Nigeria's Oil and Gas
Industry
13. A Petition
For Action - Increase The 2019 Budget To A Minimum Of N15 Trillion -Tope Fasua
14. The Greatest
Conspiracy Against Nigeria Youths
15. A Federal
Republic Of Inequality And Oppression
16. ANRP
Presidential Candidate Tope Fasua Speaks On The State Of The Nation
Related News
1.
What
Entrepreneurs Need To Know Before Entering A New Market
2. Talent is Not
Hard to Find in Africa, We Must Help Our Young To Accelerate Productivity -
Elumelu
3. Ecobank
Nigeria Gets Applause For Supporting Young Entrepreneurs
4. Tony Elumelu
Foundation Announces Opening Of Application For TEEP 2020
5. First Gem
Promotes Wealth Creation for Women In Nigeria - Adesola Adeduntan
6. 4 Tips on
Running a Restaurant Business Successfully
7. How
Coworkings Can Boost Your Productivity
8. Startup: How
to Avoid Inventory Management Mistakes
9. IFC Estimates
$1.5trn Annual Global Deficit For Women-Owned SMEs
10. Osinbajo
Calls on Banks In Nigeria To Support FG Efforts At Resuscitating MSMEs
11. CBN MPC Notes
Increase Supply of Micro-Credit to MSMEs In Nigeria
12. #WEFAfrica2019:
Increasing Opportunities for Female Entrepreneurs in Africa
13. FCMB Engages
Entrepreneurs in Oyo State, Extends free Business Finance Training
14. 5
Low-Investment Business Ideas
15. Reworking
Youth Entrepreneurship in Nigeria To Drive Growth
16. Why Youth
Investment is Critical to Africa's Transformation- Akinwunmi Adesina