Why Publishing Names of Delinquent Bank Debtors is in the Public Interest

Proshare

Sunday, December 06, 2020  / 11.37AM / OpEd By Legal Counsel* / Header Image Credit: DebtorsAfrica

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


This is a rejoinder to the post 'The CBN Directive on Publication of Delinquent Bank Debtors: Some Data Privacy Ramifications' refers.

 

By way of introduction to the issue of the legal basis of disclosing the information of debtors by Banks (which amounts to processing of such information), it is pertinent to state that it remains to be settled whether or not the fact of indebtedness is information personal to a debtor.

 

This is because the information is one jointly owned by the debtor and the creditor upon which they both have a right to use. More in the same way the name of a wife is information which the husband can use as a reference to her being his wife without needing to get consent. It is shared information not personal information. This is because the information itself is in relation to another entity.

 

For further clarity, the information that a debtor is indebted to a creditor is the economic information of the creditor as much as it is that of the debtor; and it is not information personal to anyone of them.

 

However, the issues raised in the article will be dealt with on the premise, without concession, that the fact and amount of indebtedness is economic information personal to the debtor.

 

 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


It is herein argued that there are three (3) lawful basis for disclosing (processing) the information of a debtor vis:

 

  1. First, processing is necessary for the performance of a contract to which the Data Subject is party or in order to take steps at the request of the Data Subject prior to entering into a contract;

 

The contract for obtaining the loan is a contract to which the data subject is a party. By entering into the contract, every personal information supplied can be processed and used for the purpose of performing the contract. It is important to note that the performance of the contract is not complete at the point of issuing the loan, which is only one leg of the contract, but is only complete at the point at which the loan is repaid.

 

Consequently, the bank is at liberty to use the data and information of the debtor for every action it needs to help it perform the other leg of recovering the loan. These actions can include transmission to a newspaper, a debt recovery agency, and a legal practitioner.

 

By extension, a third party is also allowed to process the information for the purpose of performing the contract which the data subject is a party to. It is important to note here that it is the data subject who is required to be a party to the contract and not the processor. Any other third party can process the information to the end that the contract might be performed. The act of publishing the names of the debtor, filing an application in court, or otherwise doing any action to recover the said debt is an action necessary for the performance of the loan contract provided that the methods of recovering the debt has not been limited by said contract. 

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd. 

 

  1. The second basis for processing the said information is because processing is necessary for compliance with a legal obligation to which the Controller is subject.

 

This is a rather glaring one as the banks are subject to regulation of the Central Bank of Nigeria as provided by the BOFIA Act. Consequently, banks are duty bound to comply with any regulation of the Central Bank to the extent that it does not conflict with any other existing law. It is important here to state that the regulation of the Central Bank does not conflict in any way with the NDPR as what the CBN requirement that banks publish the names of delinquent debtors does is to create a legal obligation which is anticipated by the NDPR thus providing an exception for banks if they had been otherwise unable to process such data.

 

The fact that the author of the directive, the CBN, is itself subject to the NDPR and to regulatory supervision by NITDA on data privacy issues does not go to the root of whether the CBN can create a legal obligation to process information on its subjects. As an illustration of this point, the National Assembly and Supreme Court are also subject to the NDPR and regulatory supervision on data privacy issues by the NITDA, it would be ridiculous to state that they cannot create a legal obligation to process data. 

 

The NITDA is not empowered to determine exactly what information any particular body can process, but only to make provisions on the circumstances under which processing can be done.

 

Lawful processing by virtue of a legal obligation is present in the NDPR in order that government agencies would not be hampered in the discharge of their legal duties and functions. The NDPR is not a super enactment that can be elevated to the position of the Constitution. Was there a legal obligation created? Yes. Is the creator of the obligation authorised to create such an obligation? the answer is also in the affirmative. Thus, it is clear that information of debtors can be processed.

 

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

  1. The third basis for processing under the circumstances is that it is necessary for the performance of a task carried out in the public interest or in exercise of official public mandate vested in the controller. This is because the issue of delinquency in the banking sector has become a systemic issue with serious implication for the banking sector and economy at large.

 

Recall that the issue of non-performing loans was so bad that the Asset Management Company of Nigeria (AMCON) had to be created to deal with the problem. The Debtors Report  particularly does an analysis of the issue of NPLs. An Executive Summary of the report is available here. Thus, the need to tackle the issue of non-performing loans is one of public interest.

 

Publishing the names of delinquent debtors is also of public interest as it aids members of the public in discerning who to go into business with. The need to rid the banking sector of delinquent debts is therefore a matter of public interest and is a lawful basis upon which information of debtors can be published. 

 

Conclusion

In summary it is important to note that the era of hiding behind the cloak of anonymity for debtors is past and a new industry approach has been adopted to aid in unmasking the character of delinquent debtors and thus reduce the exposure of the banking sector and indeed the economy to them.

 

The laws are in order and the NDPR is not a clog in the administration of this new credit regime.

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Note

The above article was written by the Proshare In-House Counsel on May 21, 2020 and since then, we have published this judgment delivered by the courts - For Publishing Debtors List - Court Dismisses N5bn Libel Suit against THISDAY, Diamond Bank - July 17, 2020

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Related Posts - NPLs and The Debt Burden

  1. Executive Summary: NPLs & Bank Debtors - The Case for a New Industry Approach - May 14, 2020
  2. (PDF) NPLs & Bad Debtors: - The Case for a New Industry Approach - Debtors Africa, May 13, 2020
  3. Operational Guidelines on Global Standard Instruction (GSI) CBN, Jul 15, 2020
  4. Memo To AMCON: Nigerian Tax Payers are not Responsible for Repayment of Bad Debt - Jul 23, 2020
  5. AMCON and Financial Services Debt Burden in Nigeria - Aug 17, 2018
  6. Key Takeaways from the CBN GSI Guidelines and the Case for a New Approach
  7. CBN Issues Operational Guidelines on GSI to Facilitate Improved Credit Repayment Culture
  8. Debtors Africa: AMCON; Chike-Obi's Alternative View
  9. Debtors Africa Launches Searchable Digital Database of Recalcitrant and Delinquent Debtors
  10. (PDF) - Coronanomics and the Nigerian Economy - Jun 06, 2020 

 


 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd. Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

Related to NPLs and Recovery

  1. Bank NPLs (25) - The Customer's Options in a New Debt Order
  2. Bank NPLs (24) - Handling Bad, Delinquent and Recalcitrant Debtors via DiMR
  3. Bank NPLs (23) - The Case for a New Approach
  4. Bank NPLs (22) - Benchmarking Best Practice and International Debtors List
  5. Bank NPLs (21) - The Role and Place of Credit Bureaus and Rating Agencies in Recovery Efforts
  6. Bank NPLs (20) - A New Cottage Industry Emerges - Debt Factors and Loan Purchase Firms
  7. Bank NPLs (19) - Issues Around Nigerian Bank Debtors List
  8. Bank NPLs (18) - Understanding The Impact Of IFRS 9 On Selected Nigerian Banks
  9. Bank NPLs (17) - IFRS and Accounting Standards
  10. Bank NPLs (16) - The Place of Arbitration, Resolution or Debt Management
  11. Bank NPLs (15) - AMCON and Its Role in Debt Recovery
  12. Bank NPLs (14) - Regulatory Guidance, Conduct and Enablers
  13. Bank NPLs (13) - Impact on Growth of the Credit Market
  14. Bank NPLs (12) - Impact of NPLs on Income Trends
  15. Bank NPLs (11) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - LDR
  16. Bank NPLs (10) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - Leverage Ratio
  17. Bank NPLs (9) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - Liquidity Ratio
  18. Bank NPLs (8) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - NPL Ratio
  19. Bank NPLs (7) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - Profitability
  20. Debtors Africa: AMCON; Chike-Obi's Alternative View
  21. Bank NPLs (6) - Technical Analysis on Banks' NPLs - Gross Earnings
  22. Bank NPLs (5) - How Banks Fared In 2018; Holding Up Against IFRS9 Tropical Winds
  23. Bank NPLs (4) - A Short History of Recovery Efforts - A Time Series Analysis
  24. Bank NPLs (3) - The State of NPLs
  25. Bank NPLs (2) - The Banking Industry and Its NPL Position
  26. Bank NPLs (DR 1) - The Case for a New Industry Approach 

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

Data Protection/Privacy

1.      Mandatory Data Privacy Compliance for Nigerian Companies - A Data Audit Offer - Mar 02, 2020

2.      New Data Privacy Compliance Considerations in Cross Border M and A Transactions Facing Africa - Oct 31, 2019

3.      The Nigeria Data Protection Regulation - Compliance Requirements

4.      Report Sets Out Governance of Key OTC Derivatives Data Elements - Oct 09, 2019

5.      The Economics of Data - Sept 23, 2019

6.      How The General Data Protection Regulation Will Affect Your Business

7.     National Data Protection Regulations - Legal Alert


 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

Related News - Debtors & Recovery


1.       The CBN Directive on Publication of Delinquent Bank Debtors: Some Data Privacy Ramifications - May 21, 2020

2.       SEPLAT Plc Refutes Being Party to Cardinal Drilling Services Loan with Access Bank

3.       O and O Networks Limited and ETI Appeal Court of Appeal Judgement on Disputed Airtel Shares

4.       AMCON Takes Over Jimoh Ibrahim's Prime Assets Over N69.4bn Debt

5.       P and ID: Nigeria's Foreign Reserves Swell by $200m

6.       P and ID Loses Again as UK Court Orders Release of $200m Guarantee to Nigeria

7.       N4bn Debt: Court Grants AMCON's Request to Take Over Firm's Asset

8.       Progress in the P and ID Case

9.       Nigeria Floors P and ID as UK Court Grants Relief from $10bn Fine

10.  AMCON: Is There Scope for Improvement in Debt Recovery?

11.  The CBN's New GSI Policy - Dangers Ahead and Recommendations

12.  Accion MFB Konnect Series: Experts Call For Clarity On Regulations for MFIs Under the GSI Framework

13.  Memo To AMCON: Nigerian Tax Payers are not Responsible for Repayment of Bad Debt

14.  For Publishing Debtors List - Court Dismisses N5bn Libel Suit against THISDAY, Diamond Bank - July 17, 2020

15.  Key Takeaways from the CBN GSI Guidelines and the Case for a New Approach

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP