Wednesday, February 06, 2019 4.00PM / Teslim Shitta-Bey
In August last year Proshare wrote a deep dive analysis on several corporate governance infractions of Fortis Micro Finance Bank, a large micro finance lender listed on the Nigeria Stock Exchange (NSE). As at the time of the report Mrs Bunmi Lawson, former Managing Director of multiple award-winning, ACCION Microfinance Bank had just resigned her appointment based on principles after being drafted to run Fortis MFB in a temporary capacity by the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) for about a year. Her resignation was, however, abrupt and raised heckles in the local media as Fortis MFB was still in a bad financial state. Lawson’s resignation was related to her putting in place the required templates for ensuring the turnaround of the bank and her difficulty in getting certain interests to carry through the required reforms and governance architecture needed to pull the bank from the brink of liquidation.
In recent weeks Lawson has been called out on her alleged poor handling of the aborted Fortis MFB rescue mission, but critics seem to have had a weak grasp of the issues that badgered and still haunt the now defunct micro lender.
Recap of the Issues
Recall that Bunmi Lawson was a recently retired award winning Managing Director/CEO of ACCION Microfinance Bank Limited; that the CBN startled by the persistent governance problems of Nigeria’s second NSE-listed microfinance bank (the other is NPF MFB) drafted Lawson in to assume the position of Chief Executive Officer of Fortis in March 2018 to stop the financial bloodletting and eliminate the operating carnage that went on under the bank’s immediate past management. Lawson’s job was, as far she was concerned, simple enough (or so she thought). It included but was not limited to:
By August 2018 (five months after her appointment) Lawson threw in the towel; from her perspective it was pretty clear that without major capital injection, creditor forbearance, sweeping management overhaul and perhaps a total makeover of the corporate brand, riding this banking horse to an expected finish line was as reasonable as expecting to find a virgin in a child labour ward. Consistent with Lawson’s proven history of diligent adherence to best global governance practices, the erstwhile bank boss, decided to end her relationship with Fortis Bank by summarily tendering her letter of resignation at the beginning of Q3, 2018, after she had put in place a framework that would assist any new management fashion a sustainable turnaround model and strategy. The resignation took effect from Friday, August 3, 2018 and was acknowledged by the bank’s spokesperson, Mr. Victor Emerson.
Proshare’s last year 2018 review noted the following:
Chart 1: Fortis MFB Price Movement 2013-2018 (N)
With the national deposit insurance company (NDIC) finally winding up the business of Fortis bank by announcing on February 4, 2019 that insured depositors of the bank should come forward with their claims, the story of Fortis MFB as a financial institution has ended, but sundry lessons persist. The episode highlights the challenges of regulatory oversight for all segment of the financial market, particularly the emerging microfinance segment which has been considered a desirable hub for promoting financial inclusion.
Analysts recall that the suspension of Fortis MFB by the NSE was not the required trigger for preemptive policy action expected from regulators but represented a weak response to the break-down in the service value proposition of the bank and reflected a persistent cycle of breaches in good corporate conduct which should have warranted a revocation of the bank’s license while safeguarding additional losses which occurred by maintain the fiction of institutional viability.
Increasingly a pattern has emerged that company’s taken over by the CBN who do not meet minimum standards of producing and making public their annual financial and management reports still maintain operational license(s).
It is worthy of note that by February 2018, Fortis MFB had said it was negotiating with its different foreign lenders to grant it a much needed financial respite by way of restructuring existing facilities. It went further to state that; with the approval and guidance of the CBN, it was also engaged in a far-reaching house cleaning exercise which meant that it was improving corporate governance standards and was preparing to live by more exacting and statutorily required rules. This was expected to lead to a leaner, healthier institution set on the path of a renewed emphasis on professionalism and adherence to international best corporate governance practices. This did not happen, as is common in Nigeria; the regulators came to the stable after the horse had bolted from the barn.
NDIC’s internment of Fortis bank still leaves unanswered the question of how market regulators will adopt preventive measures to protect investors and depositors from the bogey of operational incompetence, irrational greed and rampant cronyism; diseases that have plagued the microfinance sector for over a decade. In explaining the Fortis Bank issue in a brief discussion with Proshare, Lawson points out that, “When negotiations broke down with creditors who had over N9bln in Fortis, we the interim management team focused on getting to ensure that micro depositors who had about N2bln got paid their deposits in full. We succeeded in getting the CBN to go over and beyond to get these depositors paid off. After that it was clear that the NDIC had to liquidate the bank so I resigned as my work was complete. It was always a temporary appointment”.
The Fortis MFB saga was a disaster waiting to happen, not because of the lack of ability or experience on the part of its interim management team but because the institution was terminally ill from insider abuses that were not addressed early enough when the warning signs flickered. Treating a dead body with the best of medicines and a star-studded medical team never wakes up the deceased, well not in the case of Fortis bank.
2. NDIC shutdowns Fortis Microfinance Bank - The Nation Nigeria – Feb 04, 2019