CBN Tightens Noose on Cryptocurrency Market

Proshare

Friday, February 05, 2021 / 07:43PM / By Proshare Research / Header Image Credit: Nomad Capitalist



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


On Friday, 05 February 2021, the Central Bank of Nigeria (CBN) through a circular reference number BSD/DIR/GEN/LAB/14/001 instructed financial institutions to immediately close the accounts of persons or entities transacting in or operating cryptocurrency exchanges noting that such activities were prohibited. The Central Bank also added that "breaches of this directive will attract severe regulatory sanctions."

 

CBN and the Fear of Crypto

 

As countries globally find the categorisation of crypto currencies difficult to establish, central banks have adopted different approaches and interpretations to managing the financial 'asset'. Some countries have opted to put a lid on the use of the currency as a medium of exchange and a store of value, while others have adopted a less severe approach by permitting narrow ranges of transactions. In a country like India, just as Nigeria, the monetary authorities have leaned towards a hard break approach to cryptocurrency activities but a few Indian exchanges have started to search for a soft compromise. The Indian cryptocurrency exchanges have commenced collective initiatives to convince the Indian parliament to regulate the cryptocurrency market rather than impose an outright ban.   

 

In Nigeria, the CBN had earlier warned investors about the high risks involved in investing and trading in cryptocurrencies, sighting the problem of a lack of regulation of the market in Nigeria. However, digital currencies gained prominence in 2020 and became a subject of discussion when Nigeria's Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced its guidance on the regulation of crypto-token or crypto-coin investments which it said qualified as investments for securities transactions. The difference of opinion between the SEC and the CBN reflects the innate dilemma that cryptocurrencies represent as a tradeable asset.

 

Cryptocurrencies bear resemblance to 'collectibles' whose value is derived from perception and rarity of the item, while equally reflecting a currency as it serves as a medium of exchange and a store of value (similar to a collectible). The grey nature of the cryptocurrency's asset class has put global financial regulators in a fix (see illustration 1 below).

 

Illustration 1 Cryptocurrency: The 'Asset' Oddball

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


However, corporate finance professionals currently argue that cryptocurrencies are not 'assets' in the conventional sense, and accounting for them in company books would require deeper study.

 

From a monetary policy standpoint, regulators believe that cryptocurrencies make it difficult for Central Banks to perform their traditional functions of ensuring price stability and the promotion of economic growth. Analysts have highlighted some of the challenges involved with digital assets.

 

First, Central Banks are charged with the traditional function of maintaining price and financial stability issuing currency, both physical and electronic but the evolution of the digital assets serves as a tough grind for Central Banks in the conduct of monetary policy and supervision. The gain in the popularity of the use of cryptocurrencies largely undermines CBNs role in controlling money supply as Central Banks have no control over the supply of cryptocurrencies. The general acceptance of cryptocurrencies would affect the demand of existing money aggregates (M1, M2, and M3) which Central Banks use as instruments of monetary policy.

 

Furthermore, it has been argued by Central Bankers that cryptocurrencies are very volatile and are primarily driven by sentiments and have no fundamentals. Most Central Banks globally have argued that it is their prerogative to protect consumers from exuberant speculation and asset volatility which could to large individual and corporate financial losses.

 

In recent times there have been efforts by the CBN to reduce the number of bank-related fraud cases in the country by requesting that all accounts be linked with a unique Bank Verification Number as well as a NIN (National Identity Number). Central Bankers have, therefore, noted that cryptocurrencies heighten the risk of financial fraud as distributed ledger technology is mostly anonymous. Cryptocurrencies are stored in digital wallets, which use cryptography, that need specific codes to be granted access to the units of value in the wallet. In cases where the codes are stolen or the wallets hacked, users or holders suffer heavy losses.

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Source: CBN, NBS

 

Back to Reality

A few local monetary policy analysts have noted that the CBN's recent policy announcement would have little or no effect on crypto transactions in Nigeria. They argue that retail transactions could still be completed outside the regulated marketplace sighting the flow of peer-to-peer retail transactions involved when using digital currencies that do not need to go through official financial institutions. On the flip side, other analysts note that the policy announcement would hurt many businesses that use cryptocurrencies to transact international businesses given the scarcity of FX in the Nigerian forex market.

 

Taming the Crypto Bull

Different Central Banks have adopted a variety of regulatory measures in addressing the digital currency conundrum. For example, Some Central Banks have chosen to completely ban the use of digital currencies, others have chosen to regulate it, while some have started the process of developing an indigenous digital currency under the control of the Central Bank e.g., In 2020, China pushed one of the biggest real-world trials for its digital currency which was issued and is being controlled by the People's Bank of China. Some of the policies that have been adopted by Central Banks globally include information/moral suasion, interpretation of existing regulations, regulation of specific entities, licenses, prohibition, etc (see Table 1 below).

 

Table 1: Central Banks: Taming the Crypto Bull

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

Although some of the fears of the Central Bank of Nigeria are valid, it has been argued that there are alternative strategies that the CBN could adopt in addressing the local cryptocurrency ecosystem rather than adopting an outright prohibition. Some analysts have suggested that the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) follow through with the process in regulating cryptocurrency activities. As of last year, the SEC announced its guidelines in regulating cryptocurrencies but no new information has been released since then. Both SEC and the CBN must harmonize their positions on cryptocurrencies in Nigeria.

 

Also, economists have mentioned that the future of global electronic transactions will involve digital currencies. Although developing a digital currency requires high levels of sophistication and expertise, it has been suggested that the CBN develop its digital wallets through which cryptocurrency transactions could gain pass-throughs giving the regulator a stronger oversight of money supply and digital transactions. Unfortunately, digital payment platforms such as flutterwave are already sending messages to their customers that "In light of the recent directive by the Central Bank of Nigeria prohibiting financial institutions from engaging in cryptocurrency, we regret to inform you that we will not be able to further extend our services to support cryptocurrency use cases in Nigeria, in line with our Terms and Condition". It is questionable that in a dynamic global digital currency market that this is the way to go.


 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Last thoughts

There are a lot of unknowns and gaps that would need filling. Everyone will have to be guided by the resolution of regulatory-operator-consumer/investor grids and rules that emerge from collective engagement. While the system works towards this, it is important to keep an eye on what has worked, what could go wrong, and how the domestic market should be strategically positioned in the global flow of digital/crypto transactions. In this process guidelines and not bans or prohibitions is always the preferred and more sustainable approach.

 


Related Links and Post on the CBN Action

1.      Central Bank of Nigeria | Featured Articles: Again, CBN warns on Virtual Currencies - CBN, Feb 28, 2018

2.     Central Banking and the Cryptocurrency Challenge - Call it like it is - by Tope Fasua, Feb 07, 2021

3.     CBN Tightens Noose on Cryptocurrency Market - Proshare, Feb 05, 2021

4.     How FBI Warned FG, CBN on Scammers Using Cryptocurrencies to Defraud the West - Thisday, Feb 07, 2021

5.     Regulation of Cryptocurrency Around the World - Library of Congress

6.     A Thread Explaining What the CBN Circular Means and Why the CBN issued It - Stears Business, Feb 05, 2021

7.     CBN Circular on CRYPTOCURRENCY: CBN and SEC Singing Discordant Tunes - By Stephen Azubuike, Stephen Legal, Feb 05, 2021

8.     The Unsettling Dust over Cryptocurrency Transactions  - by James Emejo, ThisDay, Feb 07, 2021

9.     Revealed: How a Criminal Cartel Hijacked Bank Data, Demanded Ransom in Bitcoins - by Sanya Adejokun, Tribune, Feb 07, 2021

10.  Feb 05, 2021

11.   More than 1,000 cryptocurrencies have already failed - here's what will affect successes in future - by Gavin Brown and Richard WhittleThe Conversation, Nov 21, 2019

12.  Banning Cryptocurrency will Give Power to Outlaws - Emeka Okoye, Leadership, 3 years ago

13.  VIDEO: 2017 CIBN forum discussing blockchain technology in Nigeria - WebTV, 2017

14.  Banking and Bitcoin - Can Crypto Kill the Banks? - by Ivan on Tech, Sep 19, 2020

15.  Can Bitcoin Kill Central Banks? - by James MCWHINNEY, Investopedia, Jun 25, 2019

16.  Central Bank Digital Currency and its impact on the banking system: A need for a new payment system - by Zeb, Innovation & Digital, BankingHub, Aug 22, 2018

17.  Why Central Bank Digital Currencies will Destroy Bitcoin - by Nouriel Roubini, The Guardian, Nov 19, 2018

18.  (PDF) Fedcoin: A Central Bank-issued Cryptocurrency - by JP Konig, Nov 15, 2016 


Related Video

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd. Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

The first video is an excerpt from the 2017 CIBN forum discussing blockchain technology in Nigeria. Mr. Musa Jimoh (the then Deputy Director, Payments CBN) was giving the position of the banking regulator on digital currency. CBN's position has since evolved as changes occurred in adoption, infrastructure, risks & global regulation.

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - Digital Assets

1.      Legally Speaking, is Digital Money Really Money? - Jan 14, 2021

2.     Ghana Launches World's First Digital Finance Policy Amid COVID-19 - Jan 08, 2021

3.     Banks and Thrifts May Participate in INVN and Use Stablecoins for Payment Activities - Jan 05, 2021

4.     IOSCO Publishes Report on Education of Retail Investors Regarding Risks of Crypto-Assets  - Dec 24, 2020

5.     How Central Banks Can Catalyze Financial Inclusion Through Digital Currency - Oct 16, 2020

6.    Regulation of Cryptocurrency and Digital Assets In Nigeria: New Beginnings - Oct 15, 2020

7.     Stakeholders Call for Clarity in Regulation and Standardization of Nigeria's Digital Asset Market - Sep 28, 2020

8.     Digital Assets Classification Aimed at Investor Protection - SEC - Sep 21, 2020

9.     SEC Nigeria Issues Statement on Digital Assets, Their Classification and Treatment - Sep 14, 2020

10.  China Starts Major Trial of State-Run Digital Currency - Apr 30, 2020

11.   Analysts Discuss Blockchain Technology and Regulation of Digital Assets in Nigeria - Nov 18, 2019

12.  Winds of Change: The Case for New Digital Currency - Nov 15, 2018

13.  Barclays Files Two Digital Currency and Blockchain Patents with U.S. Patent Office - Jul 21, 2018

14.  Saudi Arabia Capital Market Authority Warns Investors Against Digital Currency Investment - Feb 13, 2018

15.  Distributed Ledger Tech Solutions For Settlement Of Payments Using Central Bank Digital Currency - Oct 13, 2017

16.  China Is Developing its Own Digital Currency - Mar 04, 2017

17.  Sweden's Central Bank Considers Issuing A Digital Currency - Nov 16, 2016

 

 

 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - BlockChain & Cryptos

1.      Indian Exchanges Launch Campaign Seeking to Avert Potential Crypto Ban - Coindesk - Feb 05, 2021

2.     Anchorage Granted US's First National Crypto Bank Charter

3.     Can Bitcoin Become the Next Global Reserve Currency?

4.     Banks and Thrifts May Participate in INVN and Use Stablecoins for Payment Activities

5.     How Central Banks Can Catalyze Financial Inclusion Through Digital Currency

6.     Regulation of Cryptocurrency and Digital Assets In Nigeria: New Beginnings

7.     Regulating Cryptocurrency and Initial Coin Offerings: The Nigerian Perspective - Part 2

8.     Regulating Cryptocurrency and Initial Coin Offerings: The Nigerian Perspective - Part 1

9.     BLOCKDeFi Virtual Conference and Exhibition 2020

10.  China Starts Major Trial of State-Run Digital Currency

11.   IOSCO Report Examines How Existing Regulatory Principles Could Apply to Stablecoins

12.  BIS: Central Bank Group To Assess Potential Cases For Central Bank Digital Currencies

13.  Demystifying Cryptocurrency - A Meristem Report

14.  Facebook's Libra Must Meet Strict Standards - Bank of England

15.  From Stablecoins to Central Bank Digital Currencies

16.  Digital Currencies: The Rise of Stablecoins

17.  Money And Private Currencies: Reflections On Libra

18.  UN Details How N.Korea Carried Out Crypto and SWIFT Hacks To Amass $2bn To Fund Its Nuclear Programs

19.  Do Young Nigerians Prefer Cryptocurrency for Payment?

20. Blockchain Offers Efficiency but Untested in Securitization

21.  UK Financial Conduct Authority Proposes Ban On Sale Of Crypto-Derivatives To Retail Consumers

 


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - Monetary Policy

1.      Is the Economy Spiraling? - LBS Executive Breakfast Session - February 2021

2.     Total Value of Capital Importation into Nigeria Stood at US$1,069.68m in Q4 2020 - NBS

3.     Rebasing Nigeria's GDP: New National Accounts, More Services

4.     Diaspora Remittances in Nigeria: Examining the New CBN Policy (2)

5.     Diaspora Remittances in Nigeria: Examining The New CBN Policy (1)

6.     Inflationary Pressure Still Straining Pockets

7.     CBN Deals the House Card as Policy Rates Remain Unchanged

8.     CBN Communique No. 134 of the MPC Meeting - Jan 25-26, 2021

9.     MPC Holds All Policy Parameters at the End of Its First Meeting in 2021

10.  Monetary and Interest Rate Policy in 2021: Going for Growth

11.   CBN to Sustain Expansionary Monetary Policy Till Q1, 2021 - Cordros Securities

12.  Ten MPC Members, One Shared Outlook

13.  Personal Statements By The MPC Members At The 133 MPC Meeting of Nov 23-24, 2020

14.  CBN Rolls the Dice to Tackle Market Liquidity and Dollar Dearth

15.  Implications of CBN's Introduction of Its Special Bills to the Market

16.  CBN Introduces Special Bills to Deepen the Financial Markets, An Additional Liquidity Mgmt Tool

 

 

Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


 

Related News - New Rules & Regulations in Nigeria Capital Market

1.      Crowdfunding Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

2.     Collective Investment Schemes General Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

3.     Nominee Companies Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

4.     Fund Management Products Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

5.     Payment of Administrative Charges Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

6.     Annual Supervision Fees for CIS Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

7.     Sundry Amendment to Valuation Report Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

8.     Sundry Amendment to Amount to be Underwritten Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

9.     Investment by CIS in Unlisted Securities Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

10.  Sundry Amendment to Contents of a Trust Deed Rules and Regulations in Nigeria Released by SEC

11.   Steps on Unclaimed Dividend Retrieval Process as Highlighted by SEC Nigeria

12.  SEC Requests CMOs to Disclose Security Dealings of 500,000 Units Within 24hrs of Activity

13.  Revision of Stamp Duty on NSE Transactions to 0.08% from 0.075% Effective 7th December 2020

14.  SEC Proposes Amendment to Its Rule on Renewal of Registration by CMOs

15.  SEC Issues Pre-Notice on Withdrawal of Certificates of Registration of 157 Inactive CMOs

16.  SEC to Discontinue the Practice of Issuing Prior Approval for Audited Accounts of CIS

17.  IOSCO Publishes Report on Education of Retail Investors Regarding Risks of Crypto-Assets  

 


 Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.


Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.



Proshare Nigeria Pvt. Ltd.

 

READ MORE:
Related News
SCROLL TO TOP